Media: Defining Roles

Oct 31, 2004

The , in all forms, shapes our perception of what it means to be male or female. It is a of the society and more than that, forms and moulds public opinion, reinforces certain traditional representations and helps pave the way for change. It has been noted that, for most parts, in has contained itself to the role of information dissemination and entertainment. What, then, has been the role of the in portrayal, particularly, the emergence of the woman as *almost* an equal in society?

and :
are taught that they are to be slaves to beauty, no matter how limiting, uncomfortable, fake, or dangerous it is. are objects to be admired or to be on constant display. Rarely in images do we see looking straight at us, meeting our gaze, unless they are crouched, nearly naked, or otherwise restricted or vulnerable (Dittrich, 1999).

The Beijing Platform for Action (BPFA) adopted by UN member states in 1995, looked at different issues concerned with and and (under Section J) laid down plans to address such issues. Although there has been a prominent advancement in communications , it is essential to note the continued negative and stereotyped imagery of in the . This portrayal has, of late, become increasingly violent towards and at the same time, it has been noted that while there has been a notable increase in ’s presence in institutions, particularly in television and radio, continue to have limited participation and access to decision-making in the communications industry and in governing bodies that influence . , as a region, is known for its rich cultural and traditional . However, under the garb of tradition, lie stifling and strictly-conservative rules for , leading to a defined role for .

What is needed is a gendered perspective in policies and programmes and the monitoring of content. Content analysts and experts on sensitive expression are needed to be included in the decision making and programming parts of the businesses. The negative portrayal and representation of and the embedded stereotypes to be found in the today in all South Asian countries and globally as well are a result of little or no national codes. Further, continue to have limited access and participation in decision-making in the industries and governing authorities and bodies that oversee formulation and implementation of policies. An example of an initiative taken by to promote in the (and elsewhere) was ‘Kali for ’ in , one of the leading feminist publishing houses in Asia. (One of their first books in 1984 was and in Asia). This kind of an initiative, however, proves to be too inconsequential in the larger (more popular) scheme of things. As research by Uks, a resource centre solely working on and issues, shows: most newspaper and electronic practitioners are clueless about the very concept of sensitisation to issues.

Globalisation, which makes the a tool in the hands of a few corporate bodies, sexual harassment of practitioners, and the inability of to shape programmes in the lead us to the reasons behind this phenomenon in the in . These may be narrowed down to:

• The shape of the society in our countries is extremely patriarchal,
• The ownership of the ,
• Journalism curricula and need to be sensitive as well and above all,
• Lack of ’s access to and growth in institutions (These reasons are actually a result of traditional role playing actually reinforced by the itself).

policies are lagging behind in targeting sensitive coverage. Harping on about and focusing on lewdness, immorality and illicit sexual relations will not do much to make this kind of and harassment finish. An interesting idea would be to have a South Asian and group OR a regional body which could focus on the imagery and presentation and treatment of by the and within the bodies themselves. While so much is spent by marketing research companies and advertisers on determining ’s consumer behavior, there is hardly any research on the stereotypical images of being portrayed in our . And the research which is to be found (by some very dedicated feminist researchers) is not large or influential enough to have any bearing on the state of the . In , as in the rest of , it is the houses that need to undergo this process of sensitisation and awareness.

Representation and Stereotypes:
Representations of across all tend to highlight the following attributes and in South Asian countries these are what embody femininity: Beauty, size, physique (within narrow conventions), , emotional (as opposed to rational) associations and NOT independence are the epitome of the South Asian woman as represented by the . Moreover, are often represented as being part of a context. A woman is either a mother, a daughter, a wife, a sister or the prostitute. Note: Is it not interesting that the prostitute never has any other context and if she does, she inevitably becomes part of that (the good daughter who will sacrifice and become a prostitute with a heart of gold or the ‘second woman’ who dies or runs away in favour of the good, first wife, girlfriend, mother, sister, cat!). Look at the effects of the portrayal of sexual assault of in our including video games. How is defined and shown in our , portrayed by the , judged by the journalist? Is the woman an object for advertisers? The invitational look, the hunched up model, the good woman, the docile, pretty girl—are these just terms and ideas or have they become so entrenched in our systems so as to become icons and traditions—to be followed unquestioningly.

and :
When confronted with the possibility of attending a workshop on ‘ and ’, I remember indignantly questioning the inclusion of only at such a forum. Doesn’t portray BOTH sexes—male and female? and , as a subject, is NOT to be confused with and . The drive to promote sensitisation and a gendered perspective to news, views and entertainment in the includes both the sexes. Where are slotted into a particular role, so are men and where are expected to adhere to a certain code of conduct, so are men. Again, while some would argue that are more prone to insensitive portrayal by the , why not look at it in this way: A man being stereotyped in a certain way over and over again, reinforces that idea in the minds of the public. This, in turn, makes the male act in a certain way which behaviour tends to affect the female in society. . A look at some typical male images clarifies this position.

Male Representation and Stereotypes:
Men are often neglected when we talk of bias, and stereotyping, being stereotyped as much as by today’s . The concepts of the ‘lone ranger’, ‘the Marlboro man’, the isolated aggressive hero, ‘the rugged look’ are all played and emphasized to the extent that any man who does not subscribe to the defined code laid down by such images is termed ‘effeminate’, ‘unmanly’. Strength of mind and body, independence and sexual assertiveness are attributes associated with men and mostly very particular to is the idea of the protective, possessive man’. We see the tall, dark, handsome ‘hero’, the young, hip lover who turns into a lean, mean fighting machine as soon as his ’s ‘honour’ is at stake. These social are carried by our men, leading to conflicting emotions and attitudes when they are confronted with changes in the society in which they live. Mostly, violence against is actually reinforced by the image of the strong, virile, honorable man, the man who will not accept the woman as his equal (probably due to some ‘misconceived notion of masculinity). Does this image have any negative consequences? Yes! And the loser here is again the woman. What is to be asserted is that any kind of such stereotyping of the man will eventually result in the woman being affected as well.

What Want:
A workshop on (the relationship between) ‘ and ’ held at Kathmandu under the aegis of South Asian Free Association (SAFMA) and Sancharika Samuha (a ’s initiative in ) in June 2004 brought to light many aspects of working in the . An assembly of about 50 people from across , with major representation by , looked at the basic reasons behind the lack of effective representation of in the , the stereotyping of by the and the possible ways and means. The meeting reviewed presented by the five countries on the state of and portrayal in the . Through exchange of news and data, the delegates came up with recommendations to improve the status of the female practitioner and to inculcate a sense of neutrality in reporting and disseminating information.

The recommendations to governments, NGOs and organisations are made under two specific strategic objectives:
1) increase the participation and access of to expression and decision making in and through the and new technologies of communication;
2) promote a balanced and non-stereotyped portrayal of in the .

What these recommendations brought to light was that businesses need to recognise the need for

• Inclusion of at least one-third professionals in all news and offices;
• A conducive working atmosphere for employees;
sensitive censor boards and preview committees, equally represented by and men
and cultural representation within programming;

’s inclusion in training programs, especially in areas where are under-represented.

Similarly, those in the business of and information need to:

• Resist stereotyping along , race, and sexual ethnic, class, age and grounds;
• Ensure that portrayal, representation and reporting of is non exploitative;
• Avoid that unnecessarily excludes one sex, or gives unequal treatment to either sex;
• Achieve a balance in the use of and men as experts and authorities and commentators on the full range of issues covered in the ;
• Give equal prominence to the achievement of across the full range of issues covered by the ;
• Resist any material which condones, incites or misuses representation of violence against ;
• Not report incidences of violence against which over emphasize and sensationalize irrelevant details
• Avoid presentations which imply that a person is inferior because of his or her ;
• Highlight developmental news pertaining to ;
• Acquire and ensure the approval of a survivor before publishing news regarding /abuse, violence, HIV/.

The above guidelines, unanimously approved by the participants, clarify the current drawbacks in the of both the practitioners and the houses in . In the case of , where news and entertainment channels seem to be mushrooming, there needs to be an awareness regarding the use of the female body image and the marginalisation of by slotting them into easy, simple and safe categories (beauty products and house-hold items). There also need to be courses in colleges and universities studies or journalism which focus on such issues. Only then will there be an effective female representation in the and instead of a ‘Khwateen’ only area where there are ONLY beauty and cooking tips (which are needed as well, no ), there may be other, previously un-tread, grounds covered.

Note: A follow up article with a practical look at ’s coverage and sensitisation of practitioners (editors, reporters, advertisers) is under research.