The Bhuttos

Zulfikar Ali Bhutto wrote a very good book about Pakistan and its role in the world which definitively shaped Pakistan's foreign policy especially the way ZAB played a pivotal role in bringing the US and China closer together and cracking open the anti-US eastern bloc and in one smart move creating a counterbalance to India.

Zulfikar Ali Bhutto viewed the survival of Pakistan as part of a thousand years struggle of the survival of Muslim community in the subcontinent. His own passionate love affair with Pakistan had a lot to do with how closely the Bhutto family's fortune had been intertwined with Pakistan from the start. The house in Naudero played host to Jinnah many times during Bhutto's childhood and people forget that it was the wily Sir Shahnawaz Bhutto who had managed to get the Junagadh document of accession for Jinnah thereby upsetting several British calculations.

Bhutto himself had played a key role in organizing a successful student strike in Bombay in 1946 for the Muslim League or so Bhutto claimed in his last days. This is why anyone who has read his biography is struck by how far Bhutto went to identify himself in the public perception with the memory of Jinnah. His deeply personalized involvement in the Jinnah propagation project through out 1976 and his distribution of his own photograph in the Jinnah cap was an indication of this. If there was ever a politician who was an ultra-nationalist in Pakistan it was Zulfikar Ali Bhutto.

Throughout his career as the foreign minister he subscribed to the idea that India was out to gobble up Pakistan. Remember Bhutto started his career as firmly an establishment man inducted by Sikandar Mirza and retained by Ayub Khan so he furthered the national security thesis which at the time meant extra-reliance on the US but bitter experience in the 1965 war taught Bhutto that Pakistan needed a range of options in foreign policy. The menu Bhutto created included a combo of China and US aimed at Soviet expansionism which he saw as the prime backer of India. It was this reason that forced Bhutto to famously declare that "if India makes the bomb, then we will eat grass but make our bomb".

Bhutto was a remarkable politician and a diplomat. He was no anti-imperialist though. Whatever his posturing he was at the end of the day a US ally who drove a hard bargain. Throughout his half a decade in power he continued to try and convince the US that he was a more reliable ally than the Shah of Iran. It was Bhutto who started the Afghan insurgency against the pro-communist government there at the US behest.

PPP, ZAB and BB were the greatest champions of the Kashmir cause. The Bhutto family had very close ties with the Mir Waizes and this shows in how Srinagar reacted yesterday. Kashmir and Jihad in Kashmir was a central tenet of the original PPP manifesto.
That he gave the country a unanimous constitution is an undeniable fact. Unfortunately his use of religion was theological and not as a tool of identity formation. In contrast Jinnah had to put theological issues on the backburner to bring shias, sunnis, ahmadis, ismailis, etc on one platform.
Bhutto's unfortunate action opened up a pandora's box of theological disputes. That said Ahmadis did not face persecution per se even after their constitutional excommunication. It was Zia ul Haq who tormented us.

All in all when one says that BB continued her father's mission through out her life, the mission was always the preservation of Pakistan and not some undefined imperialist agenda which the elder Bhutto used a political slogan.

For what its worth... I would never have said it 10 years ago but Benazir Bhutto as a leader and world figure was in my view head and shoulders above her famous father.

Zulfikar Ali Bhutto banked cheap popularity and often followed the sentiments of the people (Friday as a weekly holiday, ban on horse racing, alcohol and gambling... all of which he himself enjoyed... and the Ahmadi issue being a clear example of it... remember the honest and upright Khawaja Nazimuddin, the Muslim Leaguer from East Pakistan with a conservative image, had preferred to leave PMship in a similar crisis 20 years earlier instead of declaring Ahmadis kafir)... but Benazir was an intellectual and a leader who was ready finally to lead instead of being led.

This is why the loss of Benazir Bhutto is greater than that of her father. Her loss is more akin to the loss of Shaheed-e-Millat Liaqat Ali Khan who was assassinated in the same place and whose death remains a mystery. The crisis that followed paved way for Bogra and then the Military... who didn't threaten to go to Moscow, as LAK had to drive a greater bargain.

Now the world is beginning to point fingers at Pakistan's nuclear assets. The difference between all previous such events and now is that Pakistan was strong enough to withstand the sudden eliminations of Liaqat Ali Khan, Bhutto and Zia.

But Benazir Bhutto was ... as the slogan said... charon soobon ki zanjeer... the true symbol of the federation. The fact that even the Baloch nationalists cried out for her shows how above and beyond Mr. Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, Benazir had proved to be.

May Bilawal Bhutto Zardari now have the courage to follow in his illustrious mother's footsteps.