The answer is always YES

Harry Pi,
It's very generous of you to elevate your shaagird to the status of a 'brother.' (T)
Sometimes, the ustaad can and should learn from his ward. If Kaal bhayya says that what sounds the same is in reality very different, he must be right. :)

I was just thinking about right and wrong and good and bad. Is a good Hindu better than a bad Muslim? You can also say "Is Kaal Bhayya better than Scout?" The answer is YES.

Then, one can ask, "Is a good Muslim better than a bad Hindu?" Once again just ask "Is Sobia better than Chaltahai?" The answer again is YES.

Then, how about asking "Is a bad Muslim better than a bad Hindu?" Or one could ask "Is Scout better than Chaltahai?" This time the answer is YES, because she knows how to add.

Finally, one can ask "Is a good Muslim better than a good Hindu?" or one could ask "Is Sobia better than Kaal Bhayya?" The answer is again YES, because she is better looking.

So, in conclusion, I must say that the answer is always YES, as long as you pose the question correctly. :(W)