unflinching idealism ... since 1997 archivessitemapabouthelpfeedback
all are welcome to read, write and think
  • Home
  • InFocus
  • Themes
  • Columns
  • Articles
  • Fiction
  • iLogs
  • Gallery
  • Unplugged
  • Writers
  • Interactors
  • Tags
Sign in | Join Chowk
web chowk
  • Article
  • Interact
  • read writer comments
  • add to favorites
  • get rss feeds
  • print
  • email this link

Postmortem of Israeli-Hezbollah War – What Next?

Mohammad Gill August 24, 2006

Latest comments   flat   threaded   latest   oldest   all
listing 144-160   1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11

#145 Posted by Ranjit on August 27, 2006 11:09:57 pm
Re:masadi#143

[...Since when did behram become the ``lord`` of this domain. The guy is a walking talking contradiction. ...]

I thought this would never happen - but I completely agree with masadi here. Given behram`s extremely filthy, derogatory language about so many people including Indians, he is the last person on earth to pontificate about tolerance and minorities. Behram is nothing more than an uncultured buffoon with a dirty mouth. Masadi, well said!!
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#146 Posted by VRV on August 28, 2006 2:34:19 am
Re: # 134

Krishna,

The fears in British public about some radicalised Muslims are true. In fact this Ahle Hadith is spreading very fast. Unfortunately this movement was started in India not in Arabia.

As per HP talking like that. He`s an incorrigible khasi. Ignore him. But, Bombay blasts - given my working assumptions - are interlinked with Pak`s terrorism, extremist Indian Muslims and dickheads like Modi. The mainstream extremist thinking in India would eccentuate the problem than solving it.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#147 Posted by krishna_abcd on August 28, 2006 8:23:40 am
#142 by qusman1

[Just recognize the Palestinian`s right of return & compensate them for it.
....
What say, Gentoos? ]


Would you support the ``right of return`` of Jews and Christians to Mecca and Medina?

If not, why not?

What say you?

reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#148 Posted by krishna_abcd on August 28, 2006 8:35:38 am
#146 by VRV

[But, Bombay blasts - given my working assumptions - are interlinked with Pak`s terrorism, extremist Indian Muslims and dickheads like Modi.]

The previous Bombay blasts happened long before anything happened in Modi`s Gujrat. And, as I`ve said many times on Chowk before, it is easy to demonize someone without proof. If what some NGOs and others say about Modi is true then charges should be brought against him (this is the FIRST thing the opposition would do - they have done this many times before). And if found guilty, he should be hanged many times over. But this needs to be PROVED first. In a country like India, where court cases and investigations are done against the most powerful of individuals like Rajiv Gandhi etc. at the drop of a hat, I find it hard to believe that given the ``obvious`` nature of his crimes, no one sought legal action. Even the American Government, in banning Modi, said that they were going by what the UPA govt`s report said, and nothing else.

I`ve looked into newspaper reports of the incident. For every report in the un-Hindu, There are reports in a variety of other newspapers that say otherwise. There is no concrete evidence implicating him that I could find.

If you have concrete information, I would appreciate it if you shared it with me.

[The mainstream extremist thinking in India would eccentuate the problem than solving it. ]

Maybe so.



reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#149 Posted by VRV on August 28, 2006 9:41:15 am
Re: # 148

Krishna,

I proffer my mind thru email or some other board, not this one. I wrote it but it was too big and too detailed. I was in Ahmedabd on those days and I have photgraphs of Naroda Patiya, Gulberg Society and other places of Ahmedabad and Godhra S6.

I met many journalists in the English and Gujarati press based in Ahd.

On Modi: Anybody lived in Gujarat and have had a detached view of the incidents would feel that Modi was indeed culpable. Sangh was funding the defence of all riot culprits on post-Godhra riots. Jaideep Patel who lead the Naroda Patiya was given state protection and two guys who tried to attack him were killed in a police shoot-out without trail. Godhra attackers were on serious charges under IPC but none of the post-Godhra riots are facing charges. You think Modi is clean?

I prefer not to discuss more on this board.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#150 Posted by Salim_Chauhan on August 28, 2006 10:34:47 am
VRV #149,
I always knew that you were one decent, honest, and honorable man. It is people like you who restore our faith in our fellow humans. Hopefully, Krishna_abcd will learn something from this ``arjun.`` Thanks.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#151 Posted by VRV on August 28, 2006 10:49:42 am
Re: # 150

Salimbhai,

Thanks for those words.

I was in Gujarat during those days. KPS Gill the tough cop who recetnly admitted that he had sleeping problems during his Gujarat asignment. He was the guy who`d have seen worse incidents in his life as a polieman than he saw Gujarat. Still he spoke with his mind as a human being. Anthropocentrism!

I did my own research on S6 of Godhra and post-Godhra riots. I knew many details......I prefer not to go further. Of ocurse India is important for me but there is no moral crisis on this. I like India and I like humanism. I rant at people who are Koopastha Mandookams.

Like you do, I too hate bigots in all religions.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#152 Posted by Salim_Chauhan on August 28, 2006 11:00:47 am
#151, VRV {``Like you do, I too hate bigots in all religions.``}

VRV Bhai,
When the shalwars, pyjamas, dhotis, pants, and saris are removed from the corpses of the victims of rapes and murders, we are left with the remains of unfortunate beings who are very much like ourselves. Thank you for your compassion and the truth you hold paramount. I have so much respect for people like you. Somehow, I think that we are in a majority - in India, in Pakistan, in the US, UK, and even in Iraq.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#153 Posted by VRV on August 28, 2006 12:07:02 pm
Correction to Re: # 149

Godhra attackers were on serious charges under IPC but none of the post-Godhra riots are facing charges.

Pl read as

Godhra attackers were on serious charges under IPC but none of the post-Godhra riots are facing SERIOUS charges. Most of the people booked were foot-soldiers but not the kingpins of the respcetive areas.

reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#154 Posted by sattar2 on August 28, 2006 12:07:43 pm

Urstruly,

Do us all a favor and tell us what bothers you about Ahmadis? Merely calling them kaffir or airing hateful rhetoric is not an intelligent response. Try to think before responding.

And while you are at it, do explain this hadith that you yourself quoted, where the dear Prophet (pbuh) said “I am the last prophet and this mosque of mine is the last mosque”. Or at least have the decency to admit that the hadith you quoted proved you wrong. Your failure to admit such blatant errors on your part are very telling.


+++++

echoboom (#62),

Islam permits fighting jihad as a last resort and encourages believers to exhaust all other ways of negotiation and existance. Quran even commands Muslims to migrate to other lands in order to avoid persecution.

It is incorrect to call Ahmadi-Muslims as necessarily “loyal” to British. Ahmadi community has remained committed to peaceful means for resolving political conflicts. They opposed the idea of fighting jihad against British as such jihad would have been in violation of Quranic teachings. Furthermore, Ahmadi community has also opposed Iraq war from the very beginning, if this makes you feel better.

Here’s what I wrote earlier on Chowk. Click away if you must scratch this itch.

Click [Reply #62]

Click [Reply #52]

reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#155 Posted by sattar2 on August 28, 2006 12:49:14 pm

zeemax,

If you think qadiani/mirzai is a better description, you should also agree that your ilk are better described as “suicidal maniacs”. Look, your cousin Urstruly is trying to rationalize suicide bombings on the other board. What does this tell you?

It is incorrect to label those who believe in Quran as non-Muslims. It seems “Islam” has been disfigured beyond recognition by your ullema, and now you can no longer tell what is what. Read my previous post to Urstruly as it applies to you (and echo) as well.

+++

tahmed (#64),

Ahamdi views are consistent with Quranic teachings and I reckon you have misunderstood both. Furthermore, accepting a person as a prophet does not conflict with Quranic view of individual responsibility.

I doubt your viewpoint is well thought-out.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#156 Posted by Salim_Chauhan on August 28, 2006 1:15:05 pm
sattar2 #154 {``Do us all a favor and tell us what bothers you about Ahmadis?``}

Sattar Sahib,
What bothers me about Ahmadis is why they put up with the intolerance, myopia, narrow-mindedness, and stupidity of the right-wing fundo whacko Sunni Wahabbis? If someone threw me out of a club, I would start my own club and then club them on the head with it. Just look at the Baha`is and the Druze - they are happy and content without the majority from whom they originated.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#157 Posted by mirmir on August 28, 2006 1:47:36 pm
Friends...

Maybe this isn`t the place for it, but here it is anyway.

Why did it take me so long to read John Mearsheimer’s and Stephen Walt’s paper “The Israel Lobby?” Many of you may have already it, but if you haven’t I urge you, as strongly as I can, to click on the URL below. There you can select either the longer, unedited version in PDF format or the edited, shorter version. You’ll also find ample critique of the paper, both pro and con. After reading the analysis you should have a much better understanding of just why the U.S.A. invaded Iraq (incidentally that nagging puzzle - at least puzzling for me - of why the 9-11 commission didn’t do its job may also be cleared up).

From the beginning of the U.S.A.`s invasion of Iraq I`ve been adamant that oil was the prime reason for going to war. After reading John Mearsheimer`s and Stephen Walt`s splendid paper I admit that I was grossly wrong.

I urge you to read the paper, available here:

http://www.stopthewarnow.net/warlobbies/harvardpaper.html

Russ
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#158 Posted by echoboom on August 28, 2006 2:28:50 pm

Bismillah Al-Rehman Al-Raheem
Anti Ahmadiyya Movement in Islam

12th September 2001


Death of a Liar

He asked for it!!

by Dr. Rashid

``......punishment which is not by human hands but only
at the hands of God,


such as Plague and Cholera etc. deadly diseases....``

...... Mirza Qadiani


Quadianis have always tried to shroud the death of Mirza
Ghulam in mystery. If you ask them what was the cause of death of Mirza
Ghulam, they would say: Natural Cause. They claim that that he died reciting
the name of Allah etc. This article tries to trace the events leading to
his death from eye witnesses who were present at the time beside him.



The year was 1907. Erstwhile opponent of Mirza Ghulam
A Qadiani, known as Molvi Sanaullah Amratsari, had been writing incessantly
against Mirza Qadiani, exposing his writings, and openly labeling him a
Liar,Liar, Dajjal, Fabricator in his writings.

Rest of a very interesting account about the wretched Profiteer of the prophecies: ENJOY

reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#159 Posted by Ranjit on August 28, 2006 2:37:29 pm
Re:sattar2#154

[...Do us all a favor and tell us what bothers you about Ahmadis?....]

Instead of begging desperately like this with these punjoo islamic fundos, qadianis/ahmedis should throw in their lot with India. In India, you can practice your faith freely, call yourself muslim if it catches your fancy, live a life of freedom and pursue your way of life. Given that qadianis are well educated and a well-off community, India would welcome them and treat them with respect. Heck, any community that can produce a Nobel Laureate like Prof. Salam, will get my unconditional support.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#160 Posted by Behram1 on August 28, 2006 2:57:28 pm
Re: # 143 by masadi on August 27, 2006 10:29pm PT

Dear masadi:

Are you just jealous, since you are unable to make a distinction between your religious belief and your intellect. As I have consistently pointed out to you, a religious believer (am I wrong in assuming that!) like yourself can never been an authentic intellectual. You know that this thought is right. Almost all of the yester year intellectuals that I am familiar with had nothing to do with their religion.

{Since when did behram become the ``lord`` of this domain.}

No, I am not the ``lord`` of any domain. But, I would continue to use the power of my intellect to confuse the heck out of a religious believer like yourself. It is quite apparent that you have become totally confused, and have no place to take refuge.

{The guy is a walking talking contradiction.} And that is the strength of an intellect. Is it not?

{He complains when HP tells him the obvious, yet he is extremely liberal in hitting others ``below the belt`` so to speak with contrived bs. } O! Now you want to bring a alibi into the fake argument that you have created. Why? Are you so insecure to handle your little left intellect by yourself?

{He complains about the treatment of minorities in Pakistan, yet belongs to a minority group that is financially much more secure than the average Pakistani.}

Yes, and that is all the more reason that I can empathise with the unscrupulous ways the majorities have been dealing with minorities, in Pakistan.

{ He has no numbers similar to the ones that are available in the US to show the pathetic existence of minorities here with life expectency being 8 to 10 years less for African Americans and mortality at younger ages being much higher. }

Now, what has that got to do with the conversation about Starbucks? You are just showing your basic indecency when you are mixing a conversation about pigs with sheep.

Did that make any sense to you at all? It is not supposed to. That is exactly how you present your stupid empirical whatever.

{Often he talks about how he derided the Muslims from that area that try to be friendly with him, yet he talks about the condition of minorities in Pakistan.} Uh! Majorities must always, by definition, be derided. Hatred is almost universally promoted by those in the majority, does it not? If not, then where is the argument?

{This guy is a pathetic hypocrite. } Being a muslim and being a majority, you have an ingrained right to humiliate and ridicule minorities amongst you. When was the last time, a muslim society was considered right for minorities?

Well, masadi, that was too long.

{He calls for there being mutual exclusivity between intellect and belief, yet is oblivious to the fact that most intellectuals of days gone by had ``beliefs`` and what about the belief that says that using the the intellect is the surest way to the truth? }

You know very well what I mean. An indoctrinated religious belief can never be replaced by the worldly intellect. Being a religious muslim, you can never be authentic with your intellect. So stop the charade and acknowledge one or the other.

{Sorry, couldn`t hold this back seeing how he is strutting around here parading as a paragon of tolerance and enlightenment.}

And this is where your inadequacies are shown.

Respectfully submitted,
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
listing 144-160   1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11

Interact Index

    #239 krishna_abcd
    #238 krishna_abcd
    #237 krishna_abcd
    #236 Raw_Dust
    #235 tahmed32
    #234 tahmed32
    #233 krishna_abcd
    #232 krishna_abcd
    #231 krishna_abcd
    #230 krishna_abcd
    #229 krishna_abcd
    #228 Raw_Dust
    #227 AlephNull
    #226 tahmed32
    #225 Raw_Dust
    #224 tahmed32
    #223 Raw_Dust
    #222 tahmed32
    #221 tahmed32
    #220 Raw_Dust
    #219 tahmed32
    #218 tahmed32
    #217 Raw_Dust
    #216 tahmed32
    #215 tahmed32
    #214 Raw_Dust
    #213 krishna_abcd
    #212 krishna_abcd
    #211 tahmed32
    #210 tahmed32
    #209 tahmed32
    #208 tahmed32
    #207 krishna_abcd
    #206 krishna_abcd
    #205 tahmed32
    #204 krishna_abcd
    #203 tahmed32
    #202 krishna_abcd
    #201 tahmed32
    #200 tahmed32
    #199 krishna_abcd
    #198 sattar2
    #197 echoboom
    #196 sattar2
    #195 krishna_abcd
    #194 tahmed32
    #193 tahmed32
    #192 tahmed32
    #191 Behram1
    #190 sattar2
    #189 Behram1
    #188 sattar2
    #187 echoboom
    #186 sattar2
    #185 Behram1
    #184 echoboom
    #183 tahmed32
    #182 echoboom
    #181 Behram1
    #180 echoboom
    #179 Behram1
    #178 echoboom
    #177 tahmed32
    #176 tahmed32
    #175 sattar2
    #174 sattar2
    #173 zeemax
    #172 echoboom
    #171 echoboom
    #170 tahmed32
    #169 echoboom
    #168 harish_hyd
    #167 echoboom
    #166 zeemax
    #165 qusman1
    #164 tahmed32
    #163 sattar2
    #162 tahmed32
    #161 Behram1
    #160 Behram1
    #159 Ranjit
    #158 echoboom
    #157 mirmir
    #156 Salim_Chauhan
    #155 sattar2
    #154 sattar2
    #153 VRV
    #152 Salim_Chauhan
    #151 VRV
    #150 Salim_Chauhan
    #149 VRV
    #148 krishna_abcd
    #147 krishna_abcd
    #146 VRV
    #145 Ranjit
    #144 zeemax
    #143 masadi
    #142 qusman1
    #141 qusman1
    #140 Behram1
    #139 Behram1
    #138 aslam644
    #137 Behram1
    #136 faisaluno
    #135 krishna_abcd
    #134 krishna_abcd
    #133 Salim_Chauhan
    #132 Salim_Chauhan
    #131 Kamath
    #130 Salim_Chauhan
    #129 hamidm2
    #128 Urstruly
    #127 Behram1
    #126 Behram1
    #125 Behram1
    #124 Behram1
    #123 HP
    #122 zeemax
    #121 HP
    #120 VRV
    #119 zeemax
    #118 HP
    #117 krishna_abcd
    #116 zeemax
    #115 zeemax
    #114 HP
    #113 zeemax
    #112 Urstruly
    #111 zeemax
    #110 Kamath
    #109 HP
    #108 hamidm2
    #107 zeemax
    #106 echoboom
    #105 echoboom
    #104 tahmed32
    #103 tahmed32
    #102 tahmed32
    #101 zeemax
    #100 zeemax
    #99 faisaluno
    #98 krishna_abcd
    #97 nasah
    #96 zeemax
    #95 zeemax
    #94 HP
    #93 Behram1
    #92 HP
    #91 zeemax
    #90 Behram1
    #89 HP
    #88 Behram1
    #87 Behram1
    #86 HP
    #85 Behram1
    #84 Behram1
    #83 Behram1
    #82 HP
    #81 nasah
    #80 HP
    #79 hamidm2
    #78 nasah
    #77 krishna_abcd
    #76 queen_cut_paste
    #75 zeemax
    #74 krishna_abcd
    #73 aquaris
    #72 echoboom
    #71 zeemax
    #70 zeemax
    #69 tahmed32
    #68 tahmed32
    #67 zeemax
    #66 tahmed32
    #65 zeemax
    #64 tahmed32
    #63 zeemax
    #62 echoboom
    #61 zeemax
    #60 queen_cut_paste
    #59 zeemax
    #58 queen_cut_paste
    #57 queen_cut_paste
    #56 zeemax
    #55 zeemax
    #54 saharanpuri
    #53 queen_cut_paste
    #52 tahmed32
    #51 tahmed32
    #50 queen_cut_paste
    #49 queen_cut_paste
    #48 tahmed32
    #47 queen_cut_paste
    #46 tahmed32
    #45 harish_hyd
    #44 zeemax
    #43 harish_hyd
    #42 queen_cut_paste
    #41 queen_cut_paste
    #40 queen_cut_paste
    #39 zeemax
    #38 queen_cut_paste
    #37 zeemax
    #36 Behram1
    #35 echoboom
    #34 echoboom
    #33 tvarad
    #32 queen_cut_paste
    #31 freethinker
    #30 ahmer23
    #29 Salim_Chauhan
    #28 freethinker
    #27 Salim_Chauhan
    #26 queen_cut_paste
    #25 zeemax
    #24 queen_cut_paste
    #23 Salim_Chauhan
    #22 echoboom
    #21 zeemax
    #20 queen_cut_paste
    #19 queen_cut_paste
    #18 zeemax
    #17 queen_cut_paste
    #16 zeemax
    #15 harish_hyd
    #14 zeemax
    #13 zeemax
    #12 harish_hyd
    #11 iron_mask
    #10 faisaluno
    #9 ballukhan
    #8 ballukhan
    #7 HP
    #6 mantra
    #5 echoboom
    #4 tvarad
    #3 echoboom
    #2 Urstruly
    #1 Inquirer

Latest Interacts

  • harish_hyd: #252 by majumdar He believed... Living Gandhi and King
  • MantoLives: No sadna ... Our... Living Gandhi and King
  • MantoLives: Majumdar, Even Adam Khan admits... Living Gandhi and King
  • sadna: corr: I dunno about... Living Gandhi and King
  • harish_hyd: Yaar Masanamuthu, both Yasser... Living Gandhi and King
  • sadna: majumdar Everyone tried to bribe... Living Gandhi and King
  • sadna: Mantolives Your assertion that the... Living Gandhi and King
  • majumdar: Harishbhai, He believed in something... Living Gandhi and King

THEMES

  • Pakistan's Struggle for Democracy
  • The Indian Story
  • Indo-Pak Relations
  • Personal Narratives
  • Religion Today
  • War on Terror
  • Role of Media
  • Call for Social Change
  • Hold Them Accountable
  • Environment and Us
  • Way of Life
more »

Top 5 Articles This Week

  • Popular
  • Living Gandhi and King Today: Unbroken Historic Continuity
  • MQM - History and Origins
  • Reforming Religious Fundamentalists
  • Fathers and Daughters
  • A Weak Pakistan is a Threat to Neighbours
  • Featured
  • There are a Lot of Monkeys
  • White Charade
  • Words of a Woman
  • FOX News and the Smelly Shoes
  • Dilemmas of Creative Children
  • 10 Years Ago
  • Raj and I
  • Man or mouse
  • Extra-judicial Executions
  • Ranjha
  • A Consummate Professional

Write on Chowk Interact Guidelines Privacy policy Terms Contact

Copyright © 1997 - 2008 chowk.com. All Rights Reserved
Reproduction of material on any www.chowk.com pages without prior written permissions is strictly prohibited