A Letter To President Musharraf
Khadija Hassan July 13, 2007
#239 Posted by neembu on July 16, 2007 5:06:44 am
July 16, 2007
Aid to Pakistan in Tribal Areas Raises Concerns
By JANE PERLEZ
GHALANAI, Pakistan — The United States plans to pour $750 million of aid into Pakistan’s tribal areas over the next five years as part of a “hearts and minds” campaign to win over this lawless region from Qaeda and Taliban militants.
But even before the plan has been fully carried out, documents and officials involved in the planning are warning of the dangers of distributing so much money in an area so hostile that oversight is impossible, even by Pakistan’s own government, which faces rising threats from Islamic militants.
Who will be given the aid has quickly become one of the most contentious questions between local officials and American planners concerned that millions might fall into the wrong hands. The local political agents and tribal chiefs in this hinterland on the Afghan border have for years accommodated the very groups the American and Pakistani governments seek to drive out.
A closely scripted visit to the hospital here, used for a pilot project by the United States Agency for International Development, showed the challenges on full display. The one-story hospital here was virtually empty on a recent day.
Local people had no way to get there. Three of the 110 beds were occupied. Two operating tables had not been used in months. Many doctors had left because the pay was too meager and security too precarious, said Dr. Yusuf Shah, the chief surgeon.
Sher Alam Mahsud, the local political boss who escorted this reporter on a rare visit, said he wanted all the American aid money “delivered to us.” But the precarious security does not allow the Americans to assess the aid priorities firsthand, or to provide oversight for the first installment of $150 million allocated by the Bush administration.
“Delivering $150 million in aid to the tribal areas could very quickly make a few people rich and do almost nothing to provide opportunity and justice to the region,” said Craig Cohen, the author of a recent study of United States-Pakistan relations at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington. Yet it is here in Pakistan’s Federally Administered Tribal Areas, or FATA, as the region is formally called, that Washington is intent on using the development aid as a counterinsurgency tool, according to a draft of the Agency for International Development plan given to The New York Times by an official who worked on it.
The draft warns that the “severe governance deficiencies” in the tribal areas will make it virtually impossible for the aid to be sustainable or to overcome the “area’s chronic underdevelopment and consequent volatility.”
The ambitious plan was publicly highlighted during a visit to Pakistan in June by Richard A. Boucher, the assistant secretary of state for South and Central Asian affairs, as a measure of Washington’s support for Pakistan’s president, Gen. Pervez Musharraf.
“The objective driving this decision is the hope that by bringing the FATA into the mainstream and assuring that basic human services and infrastructure are on par with the rest of Pakistan, the people of FATA would be less likely to welcome the presence of Al Qaeda and Taliban,” the draft states. The projects include health and education services, water and sanitation facilities, and agricultural development, it says, making clear that these are a means to a broader end. “The main goal of the United States government in relation to the FATA is counterterrorism,” it says.
One way to improve the chances of the aid’s efficacy would be greater emphasis on political reform in the tribal areas, according to the draft. The Pakistani government has created a panel to study reform of the political structure in the areas, the draft noted, adding that “Usaid should explore opportunities for contributing its substantial experience in local government capacity building to any reform efforts the government of Pakistan decide to undertake.”
Even if the tribal areas were not under the sway of the Taliban, which they increasingly are, the development challenge here would be steep enough, the document and interviews make clear.
The area, home to 3.2 million people, remains a desolate landscape where women are strictly veiled. Female literacy — at 3 percent — is among the lowest in the world. Schools are often used to run businesses. There is no banking system. Smuggling of opium and other contraband is routine.
The hostility to almost anything that smacks of foreign influence is such that money from the modest development agency program, administered by the charity Save the Children at the hospital here, was being delivered anonymously, undercutting any potential public relations benefit for the United States.
“We can’t do branding,” said Fayyaz Ali Khan, the program manager for Save the Children, in an interview in the city of Peshawar. “Usually we say the aid comes from the American people, but here we can’t.”
Suspicions about modern medicine are rife. A Pakistani doctor was blown up in his car in June after trying to counter the anti-vaccine propaganda of an imam in Bajaur, one of the tribal agencies, Pakistani officials said.
The Pakistani government has virtually no authority here. After years of fighting to assert its authority, at the cost of about 600 soldiers, it negotiated peace accords with tribal authorities that have all but confined Pakistani troops to their barracks.
Tribal elders, local imams and governors known as political agents — their title goes back to the British colonial days — are the on-the-ground arbiters of all decisions in many districts. The political agents are widely considered corrupt.
A senior American official in Islamabad, Pakistan’s capital, who would not speak for attribution, defended the plan’s goals as necessary and achievable. The official said that “Pakistani firms, consulting organizations and nongovernmental organizations” would be the main deliverers of the assistance.
The official said, referring to the international aid agency, that these would in turn be “managed under Usaid direct contracts and grants to American and international organizations.”
Mr. Cohen, of the Center for Strategic and International Studies, was skeptical. Almost every potential recipient of the money was suspect in the eyes of the people it was supposed to help, he said. “The notion that there’s going to be $150 million a year to Pakistani nongovernmental organizations who are going to be out in the open seems naïve to me,” he said.
“The insecurity of the area will require a heavy reliance on local partners” like Pakistani nongovernmental organizations to administer projects, he added. “But the nongovernmental organizations don’t trust the military, the military doesn’t trust the tribal chiefs, and the tribal chiefs won’t trust us unless they’re getting a cut of the money.”
Such Pakistani groups were often targets of the Islamic militants in the tribal areas. The militants are increasingly destroying CD shops and attacking small efforts to gain advantages for women.
Mr. Mahsud, the political agent for the tribal agency, or district, of Mohmand, where the hospital is, had his own ideas. Any aid money from Western donors should be “pooled here,” he said, during an interview at the FATA secretariat headquarters in Peshawar, meaning it should be distributed through local officials.
His power was evident when he drove in his impressive new four-wheel-drive vehicle through the heavy metal black gates that mark the boundary to his tribal agency. Armed men in heavy gray uniforms, wearing black felt berets in the summer heat, snapped to attention.
The hospital itself was barren, and silent. Dr. Shah, the chief surgeon, and other doctors who had come to the hospital for the visit of an outsider, said water was a luxury trucked in by tanker, arriving at best every other day.
One doctor, Aaquila Khan, brimmed with passion about helping the poor and feeble women who came to visit the woefully underequipped hospital, but she lives in Peshawar, more than an hour’s drive away, and so comes in just two or three days a week, mornings only, to treat those female patients.
“They are very much anemic,” she said of eight women she treated during a recent visit. “They are not educated, they are not aware of family planning, they have no money.” Only the women living within walking distance could come, she said.
The aid program run by Save the Children, a small $11 million starter project that hints at the bigger things planned by the Americans, formally began last December with a signing of a memorandum of understanding with the tribal authorities.
The idea is for Pakistani doctors to train health care workers who will go into the field and train traditional health assistants on more modern methods.
But the first training sessions have only just begun, said Mr. Khan, the program manager for Save the Children. The only sign of the program was a “resource room” with a large blond wood table and a dozen or so chairs still in their plastic wrapping.
The training sessions take place in Peshawar, over the tribal boundary, to ensure the safety of the doctors.
Copyright 2007 The New York Times Company
Aid to Pakistan in Tribal Areas Raises Concerns
By JANE PERLEZ
GHALANAI, Pakistan — The United States plans to pour $750 million of aid into Pakistan’s tribal areas over the next five years as part of a “hearts and minds” campaign to win over this lawless region from Qaeda and Taliban militants.
But even before the plan has been fully carried out, documents and officials involved in the planning are warning of the dangers of distributing so much money in an area so hostile that oversight is impossible, even by Pakistan’s own government, which faces rising threats from Islamic militants.
Who will be given the aid has quickly become one of the most contentious questions between local officials and American planners concerned that millions might fall into the wrong hands. The local political agents and tribal chiefs in this hinterland on the Afghan border have for years accommodated the very groups the American and Pakistani governments seek to drive out.
A closely scripted visit to the hospital here, used for a pilot project by the United States Agency for International Development, showed the challenges on full display. The one-story hospital here was virtually empty on a recent day.
Local people had no way to get there. Three of the 110 beds were occupied. Two operating tables had not been used in months. Many doctors had left because the pay was too meager and security too precarious, said Dr. Yusuf Shah, the chief surgeon.
Sher Alam Mahsud, the local political boss who escorted this reporter on a rare visit, said he wanted all the American aid money “delivered to us.” But the precarious security does not allow the Americans to assess the aid priorities firsthand, or to provide oversight for the first installment of $150 million allocated by the Bush administration.
“Delivering $150 million in aid to the tribal areas could very quickly make a few people rich and do almost nothing to provide opportunity and justice to the region,” said Craig Cohen, the author of a recent study of United States-Pakistan relations at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington. Yet it is here in Pakistan’s Federally Administered Tribal Areas, or FATA, as the region is formally called, that Washington is intent on using the development aid as a counterinsurgency tool, according to a draft of the Agency for International Development plan given to The New York Times by an official who worked on it.
The draft warns that the “severe governance deficiencies” in the tribal areas will make it virtually impossible for the aid to be sustainable or to overcome the “area’s chronic underdevelopment and consequent volatility.”
The ambitious plan was publicly highlighted during a visit to Pakistan in June by Richard A. Boucher, the assistant secretary of state for South and Central Asian affairs, as a measure of Washington’s support for Pakistan’s president, Gen. Pervez Musharraf.
“The objective driving this decision is the hope that by bringing the FATA into the mainstream and assuring that basic human services and infrastructure are on par with the rest of Pakistan, the people of FATA would be less likely to welcome the presence of Al Qaeda and Taliban,” the draft states. The projects include health and education services, water and sanitation facilities, and agricultural development, it says, making clear that these are a means to a broader end. “The main goal of the United States government in relation to the FATA is counterterrorism,” it says.
One way to improve the chances of the aid’s efficacy would be greater emphasis on political reform in the tribal areas, according to the draft. The Pakistani government has created a panel to study reform of the political structure in the areas, the draft noted, adding that “Usaid should explore opportunities for contributing its substantial experience in local government capacity building to any reform efforts the government of Pakistan decide to undertake.”
Even if the tribal areas were not under the sway of the Taliban, which they increasingly are, the development challenge here would be steep enough, the document and interviews make clear.
The area, home to 3.2 million people, remains a desolate landscape where women are strictly veiled. Female literacy — at 3 percent — is among the lowest in the world. Schools are often used to run businesses. There is no banking system. Smuggling of opium and other contraband is routine.
The hostility to almost anything that smacks of foreign influence is such that money from the modest development agency program, administered by the charity Save the Children at the hospital here, was being delivered anonymously, undercutting any potential public relations benefit for the United States.
“We can’t do branding,” said Fayyaz Ali Khan, the program manager for Save the Children, in an interview in the city of Peshawar. “Usually we say the aid comes from the American people, but here we can’t.”
Suspicions about modern medicine are rife. A Pakistani doctor was blown up in his car in June after trying to counter the anti-vaccine propaganda of an imam in Bajaur, one of the tribal agencies, Pakistani officials said.
The Pakistani government has virtually no authority here. After years of fighting to assert its authority, at the cost of about 600 soldiers, it negotiated peace accords with tribal authorities that have all but confined Pakistani troops to their barracks.
Tribal elders, local imams and governors known as political agents — their title goes back to the British colonial days — are the on-the-ground arbiters of all decisions in many districts. The political agents are widely considered corrupt.
A senior American official in Islamabad, Pakistan’s capital, who would not speak for attribution, defended the plan’s goals as necessary and achievable. The official said that “Pakistani firms, consulting organizations and nongovernmental organizations” would be the main deliverers of the assistance.
The official said, referring to the international aid agency, that these would in turn be “managed under Usaid direct contracts and grants to American and international organizations.”
Mr. Cohen, of the Center for Strategic and International Studies, was skeptical. Almost every potential recipient of the money was suspect in the eyes of the people it was supposed to help, he said. “The notion that there’s going to be $150 million a year to Pakistani nongovernmental organizations who are going to be out in the open seems naïve to me,” he said.
“The insecurity of the area will require a heavy reliance on local partners” like Pakistani nongovernmental organizations to administer projects, he added. “But the nongovernmental organizations don’t trust the military, the military doesn’t trust the tribal chiefs, and the tribal chiefs won’t trust us unless they’re getting a cut of the money.”
Such Pakistani groups were often targets of the Islamic militants in the tribal areas. The militants are increasingly destroying CD shops and attacking small efforts to gain advantages for women.
Mr. Mahsud, the political agent for the tribal agency, or district, of Mohmand, where the hospital is, had his own ideas. Any aid money from Western donors should be “pooled here,” he said, during an interview at the FATA secretariat headquarters in Peshawar, meaning it should be distributed through local officials.
His power was evident when he drove in his impressive new four-wheel-drive vehicle through the heavy metal black gates that mark the boundary to his tribal agency. Armed men in heavy gray uniforms, wearing black felt berets in the summer heat, snapped to attention.
The hospital itself was barren, and silent. Dr. Shah, the chief surgeon, and other doctors who had come to the hospital for the visit of an outsider, said water was a luxury trucked in by tanker, arriving at best every other day.
One doctor, Aaquila Khan, brimmed with passion about helping the poor and feeble women who came to visit the woefully underequipped hospital, but she lives in Peshawar, more than an hour’s drive away, and so comes in just two or three days a week, mornings only, to treat those female patients.
“They are very much anemic,” she said of eight women she treated during a recent visit. “They are not educated, they are not aware of family planning, they have no money.” Only the women living within walking distance could come, she said.
The aid program run by Save the Children, a small $11 million starter project that hints at the bigger things planned by the Americans, formally began last December with a signing of a memorandum of understanding with the tribal authorities.
The idea is for Pakistani doctors to train health care workers who will go into the field and train traditional health assistants on more modern methods.
But the first training sessions have only just begun, said Mr. Khan, the program manager for Save the Children. The only sign of the program was a “resource room” with a large blond wood table and a dozen or so chairs still in their plastic wrapping.
The training sessions take place in Peshawar, over the tribal boundary, to ensure the safety of the doctors.
Copyright 2007 The New York Times Company
reply to this interact
write a new interact
add to favorites
flag objectionable content
#240 Posted by arjun2 on July 16, 2007 5:10:41 am
#208 Posted by bulleya on July 15, 2007 11:57:08 pm
1. pakistan needs to get out of the habit of being a frontline state for usa
Oh so NOW you think that, huh?
Just after 9/11, you were chaffing at the bit to join the invasion of afghanistan. You wouldn't shut up about how pakiland was the talk of the town and how they were talking about pakiland on all TV shows.
p.s. what a pathetic attempt to redesign chowk. What's the idea? web 2.0?
1. pakistan needs to get out of the habit of being a frontline state for usa
Oh so NOW you think that, huh?
Just after 9/11, you were chaffing at the bit to join the invasion of afghanistan. You wouldn't shut up about how pakiland was the talk of the town and how they were talking about pakiland on all TV shows.
p.s. what a pathetic attempt to redesign chowk. What's the idea? web 2.0?
#241 Posted by Folio on July 16, 2007 5:28:18 am
Re: # 226
Asadi,
Did u write some bad response (coz 227 is missing from here).
Asadi,
Did u write some bad response (coz 227 is missing from here).
#242 Posted by harish_hyd on July 16, 2007 5:30:02 am
#240 Posted by arjun2
{Oh so NOW you think that, huh?}
Yaar Arjun, you must have followed Romair's chequered posting history more than anyone else, and he has said everything on every topic under the sun and everything exactly contradictory to it at some point of time. So it is pointless really, to remind him of that. Water off a duck's back I guess.
{Oh so NOW you think that, huh?}
Yaar Arjun, you must have followed Romair's chequered posting history more than anyone else, and he has said everything on every topic under the sun and everything exactly contradictory to it at some point of time. So it is pointless really, to remind him of that. Water off a duck's back I guess.
#243 Posted by hamidm2 on July 16, 2007 5:34:19 am
chowk staff,
....... i like your new format if no other reason that it is driving masadi and the mullahs mad ! ....... but you might want to consider listing the interacts chrononologically instead of nesting - nobody here pays any attention to who responds to who and people tend to read the latest interacts regardless of who responded to who ...... other than that the new format is great ....
#244 Posted by hamidm2 on July 16, 2007 5:40:04 am
chowk staff,
... while you are at it, can you also ban philosopher until he turns 21 ...... thanks ....... also, you might want to ban arjun - he has become woefully boring; even after all these years he doesn't realize that we have already read all the stuff in dawn by the time he posts it ...
#245 Posted by zeemax on July 16, 2007 5:49:13 am
Re: # 236 Yeah dunno why they did it ... the previous format was unique and this looks like loads of other mediocre chat sites .... besides I don't know what is all that empty space on the right is doing where all the interacts used to be listed so one could only read the good interactors and not HAVE to read all the monkeys and the apes in the process ... :(
#246 Posted by zeemax on July 16, 2007 5:49:54 am
Re: # 236 Yeah dunno why they did it ... the previous format was unique and this looks like loads of other mediocre chat sites .... besides I don't know what is all that empty space on the right is doing where all the interacts used to be listed so one could only read the good interactors and not HAVE to read all the monkeys and the apes in the process ... :(
#247 Posted by philosopher on July 16, 2007 5:50:12 am
Re: # 243
meeday mussalli
Are you consciously aware of the fact that you are complete waste of human brain cells and other sophisticated organs.If you have brain transplant i am sure brain would reject your already messed up ''khoupri'' and dirty old body.
You are kind of a trash which was used as a blueprint to build idiots and buffoons.your filthy existence forces me to believe in the punishments of stoning and lashes.
gadhay....i know...you too like the old format.....please support us man....ok what are your demands....what do you want me to do(it shouldn't have anything to do with religion).
meeday mussalli
Are you consciously aware of the fact that you are complete waste of human brain cells and other sophisticated organs.If you have brain transplant i am sure brain would reject your already messed up ''khoupri'' and dirty old body.
You are kind of a trash which was used as a blueprint to build idiots and buffoons.your filthy existence forces me to believe in the punishments of stoning and lashes.
gadhay....i know...you too like the old format.....please support us man....ok what are your demands....what do you want me to do(it shouldn't have anything to do with religion).
#248 Posted by tahmed32 on July 16, 2007 5:51:48 am
Hamidm you peon!! This change in format is a conspiracy of the evil West to get disrupt the Great Thinker Masadi's thought processes. His ilog is lost forever. Mankind will have to wait another 1000 years before another Masadi is born. :-(
#249 Posted by philosopher on July 16, 2007 5:52:10 am
Re: # 243
meeday mussalli
Are you consciously aware of the fact that you are complete waste of human brain cells and other sophisticated organs.If you have brain transplant i am sure brain would reject your already messed up ''khoupri'' and dirty old body.
You are kind of a trash which was used as a blueprint to build idiots and buffoons.your filthy existence forces me to believe in the punishments of stoning and lashes.
gadhay....i know...you too like the old format.....please support us man....ok what are your demands....what do you want me to do(it shouldn't have anything to do with religion).
meeday mussalli
Are you consciously aware of the fact that you are complete waste of human brain cells and other sophisticated organs.If you have brain transplant i am sure brain would reject your already messed up ''khoupri'' and dirty old body.
You are kind of a trash which was used as a blueprint to build idiots and buffoons.your filthy existence forces me to believe in the punishments of stoning and lashes.
gadhay....i know...you too like the old format.....please support us man....ok what are your demands....what do you want me to do(it shouldn't have anything to do with religion).
#250 Posted by ZahraJ on July 16, 2007 5:54:05 am
Chowk Admin - Nice layout for threaded conversations! Font looks fine. Sweet!
#251 Posted by ZahraJ on July 16, 2007 5:55:03 am
Re: # 236
"strain on the eyes"
You need better glasses :)
"strain on the eyes"
You need better glasses :)
#252 Posted by ZahraJ on July 16, 2007 5:55:03 am
Re: # 236
"strain on the eyes"
You need better glasses :)
"strain on the eyes"
You need better glasses :)
#253 Posted by tahmed32 on July 16, 2007 6:00:27 am
philosopher/zeemax: You are having trouble adjusting to change. Hamidm is happy and likes the new format, and easily adjusts to change.
There is a moral hiding in there somewhere (Hint: change in chowk format, or change around the world. Some people get it right away, others get it after a lot of discomfort, and a few go through life never getting it).
There is a moral hiding in there somewhere (Hint: change in chowk format, or change around the world. Some people get it right away, others get it after a lot of discomfort, and a few go through life never getting it).
#254 Posted by arjun2 on July 16, 2007 6:06:50 am
he he
Pakistan Truce Appears Defunct
Insurgents Strike Police, Troops; At Least 44 Die
By Griff Witte and Imtiaz Ali
Washington Post Foreign Service
Monday, July 16, 2007; Page A01
ISLAMABAD, Pakistan, July 15 -- A controversial peace deal between the Pakistani government and local tribal leaders in an area where al-Qaeda is known to be regrouping appeared to collapse Sunday, as tensions escalated and a fresh wave of bombings killed at least 44 people.
The 10-month-old deal in the restive region of North Waziristan was designed to curb cross-border attacks against U.S. and NATO troops in Afghanistan. But it has been widely criticized by security analysts and, lately, U.S. officials, who said it provided terrorist groups including the Taliban and al-Qaeda with a safe haven in which to train recruits and plot attacks.
Pakistan Truce Appears Defunct
Insurgents Strike Police, Troops; At Least 44 Die
By Griff Witte and Imtiaz Ali
Washington Post Foreign Service
Monday, July 16, 2007; Page A01
ISLAMABAD, Pakistan, July 15 -- A controversial peace deal between the Pakistani government and local tribal leaders in an area where al-Qaeda is known to be regrouping appeared to collapse Sunday, as tensions escalated and a fresh wave of bombings killed at least 44 people.
The 10-month-old deal in the restive region of North Waziristan was designed to curb cross-border attacks against U.S. and NATO troops in Afghanistan. But it has been widely criticized by security analysts and, lately, U.S. officials, who said it provided terrorist groups including the Taliban and al-Qaeda with a safe haven in which to train recruits and plot attacks.
Interact Index
Latest Interacts
- hamidm2: Re: # 54 pardesi mian, "No... Pleas For Sanity as
- GT: Dear tahmed: It sounds very... Pleas For Sanity as
- nkg: bori beduin http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/7758930.stm we need to... India-Pakistan: Empathy, grief in
- Pardesi: #64 I am talking... Pleas For Sanity as
- KaalChakra: Tahmedji, the good thing... Pleas For Sanity as
- tahir: NGK, mind your separatists... The Future of Indo
- nkg: "2- Unless both India... The Future of Indo
- chaltahai: Ok...can we have pakistani... Pleas For Sanity as
