unflinching idealism ... since 1997 archivessitemapabouthelpfeedback
all are welcome to read, write and think
  • Home
  • InFocus
  • Themes
  • Columns
  • Articles
  • Fiction
  • iLogs
  • Gallery
  • Unplugged
  • Writers
  • Interactors
  • Tags
Sign in | Join Chowk
web chowk
  • Article
  • Interact
  • read writer comments
  • add to favorites
  • get rss feeds
  • print
  • email this link

Hindu Mathematics – How Original Was It?

Pervez Hoodbhoy June 15, 2009

Latest comments   flat   threaded   latest   oldest   all
listing 1-16   1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11

#297 Posted by meenug on October 8, 2009 10:12:20 am
In 498 CE, Indian mathematician and astronomer Aryabhata stated that "Sthanam sthanam dasa gunam" or place to place in ten times in value, which may be the origin of the modern decimal-based place value notation.


The oldest known text to use a decimal place-value system, including a zero, is the Jain text from India entitled the Lokavibhaga, dated 458 CE. This text uses Sanskrit numeral words for the digits, with words such as the Sanskrit word for void for zero. The first known use of special glyphs for the decimal digits that includes the indubitable appearance of a symbol for the digit zero, a small circle, appears on a stone inscription found at the Chaturbhuja Temple at Gwalior in India, dated 876 CE.

There are many documents on copper plates, with the same small o in them, dated back as far as the sixth century CE, but their authenticity may be doubted.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/0_(number)

http://www.timelineindex. com/content/view/1452
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#296 Posted by vakibs on August 26, 2009 2:31:38 am
Zero invented in China ? :) I don't even want to read the book if it's as ridiculous as that.. The decimal method of counting with zeros is inherent to Indian philosophical tradition, going back to the Samkhya system (which means enumeration). It is written all over Indian culture and tradition. Arguing against is kinda silly, because there's really no substance.

http://the-redpill.blogspot.com/2006/09/c-o-u-n-t-i-n-g-w-i-t-h-z-e-r-o-e-s. html

One of the best champions of Indian mathematics, cosmology and philosophy was Al Biruni, who studied most closely Sanskrit scriptures. Earlier to him was Pythagoras, who for all practical purposes was a follower of Vedic Brahmin religion.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#295 Posted by RanaRajputana on August 11, 2009 5:29:55 am
Re: # 277
A very big lie, perpetuated by the Islamic Media and lapped up hungrily by the Dhimmi Western Media
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#294 Posted by foggy1 on August 3, 2009 9:29:40 am
Re: # 293
after the first para of the above, i'd like to quote this:
"But, all said and done, mathematics is mathematics. The bottom line is that a quadratic equation solved by whoever and by whatever means has to give exactly the same solutions. "
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#293 Posted by foggy1 on August 3, 2009 9:27:23 am
the far eastern neighbor of India,certainly seems to have the edge as far as the ancient story of maths goes.the former may very well be more ancient, according to the statement in your article.someone or the other is always vying for something.
another thing which equalizes any imbalance forseeable, in maths versus the people who use it is ;
the other day i was reading online comments by IT professionals.they did not belong to pakistan.i gathered,that when it was new, there were many people pouring into the field, and found it lucrative.but now the same people who are senior and very experienced find that when their contract ended, it was not renewed.they had the experience but were not getting jobs in their field because of age.coming to the present day, fresh graduates in the field of IT are not given jobs because of lack of experience and real world training.the object of their envy are immigrants, with IT qualifications who work for less remuneration.also outsourcing giants like India, which seems to have suffered little setback owing to its giant scam, also seems to be the source of envy.one of the senior IT onliner remarked, that IT should not be taught as an exclusive course in an IT teaching institution anymore.he suggested a combined degree. i cannot picture what this means.but i got an idea and liked it, that it must be taught at different levels; from school to college to university with other subjects.especially medical colleges and universities.where different packages would be available depending on the duration, short courses, long, and full fledged ones where you could get a bs or msc or PhD in it.also all those medical students studying the subject of IT, could take up research, and software designing and production according to the medical needs at the industrial level, medical interpersonal level, at adminstrative, at equipment, LAB investigativelevels, at staff, patients, student, and teachers level.
another point raised by the foreign ‘onliner was-the level of IT teaching.i understood that he meant 2 levels, already exist, according to the types of students.one is the short, familiarisation level where the students only want to know about computer/internet basic, mostly the software and applications part, so that they can rush and get up to their social networks and stick there.mostly chatting or may be making up for their absence at school, by taking missed notes or doing online homework.and the other level is the advanced level, where the brilliant ones in the IT field are left after the scum has spilled over to limn the internet with its twitter/chatter.these young people can really take to the advanced IT.in hi school, colleges and universities and go in for hi IT research innovations and developments and products used for their own professional subjects which degree courses they are also pursuing in the same institutions!a doctor a scientist ,engineer, lawyer, banker, artist, innovator, entrepreneur, administrator who is himself an IT expert -is indeed Master of all he surveys!
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#292 Posted by bhs75 on July 4, 2009 9:16:05 pm
would like to suggest a good reading if anyone can find it online,

Islam & Science - Religious orthodoxy and battle for rationality -

by:

Prof. Pervez Amirali Hoodbhoy
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#291 Posted by echoboom on June 21, 2009 7:10:08 pm
=== Interact Filtered ===
view this users filtered interacts
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#290 Posted by saab900s on June 21, 2009 1:41:23 pm
=== Interact Filtered ===
view this users filtered interacts
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#289 Posted by CoolAL on June 21, 2009 5:47:55 am
#286

Now your bravery matches the glorius "Tiger" Niazi who used 155mm artillary against defenseless students in Dhaka University and did got his butt handed to him on a plate.

The Indian Army had to "Protect" him from his own people after his surrender.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#288 Posted by major on June 20, 2009 11:55:26 am
Re: # 286 GF
[...you sound like a truly brave warrior...]

Thanks man, you are too... you are the bravest of them all - who else can claim with straight face that pakis never did ethnic killing... LOL
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#287 Posted by pinku on June 19, 2009 9:09:23 pm
#268 Posted by bulleya on

Bulleya, India was called Aryavrata, though in later times there were distinct mahajanpads in the area now called afganistan, pakistan and northern India (plus middle part of India as well). Area close to delhi is called jambudeep in sanskrit parayer shlokas etc. Even today the same shlokas/mantras are recited during important hindu ceremonies.

The religion was simply called "dharm", which they later started calling snantan dharm


So Hinduism or that "dharm" as a unifying factor predates the idea of India/Bharat/Aryavrata created by any one, whether greeks, persians, arabs or british, or Hindu themselves, but India as a separate almost protected land mass with lots of population predates even the idea of Hinduism/Dharma. It is possible that dravidians are living in India since as long as africans in africa. And most probably Hinduism and its mythology borrows a lot from the old dravidian culture that got mixed with Aryan's culture. It is almost impossible to think of Shiv and Krishn as blue/black God for so called pure white Aryans
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#286 Posted by Goldfinger on June 19, 2009 1:44:29 pm
Re: # 280, 281

major...you sound like a truly brave warrior...almost as brave as your forebears in the not too distant a past when they fought just as bravely against the Chinese in 1962...when just someone calling out "Chinese!" was enough to induce sprints away from the field of battle which could create record times in the Olympic games (otherwise people being too stunted to do so in real Olympics)...condoning acts of violence and brutality against a section of hapless civilians of your own country...how great indeed this Shining India must be to live in! Where otherwise hunger, poverty, starvation are rampant...
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#285 Posted by GT on June 19, 2009 1:00:09 pm
Sanskrit mathematical shlokas remind me of :

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RNC-aj76zI4
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#284 Posted by kaurasach on June 19, 2009 10:59:17 am
another petty rant by the thieves -


Plate pissers, who haven't made a single contribution to civilized world, and stole and copied everything from others, including their rituals from the Jews; they are horrified and petty to admit others' achievements.

Yes, the mughals are called great, but the contributors to the greatness were the conquered and the converted.......same goes for the Central Asian empires.

A modern example is Dubai - it is a great place (relatively speaking) but its greatness is from the contributions of foreigners.

reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#283 Posted by CoolAL on June 19, 2009 8:53:45 am
#279

Dude, I find your naiivete absolutely astounding. Let us see, your point is that India influenced the Bengalis to revolt against you Pakis and so it is all -- ok ok 50% --Inida's fault.

If your treatment of Bengalis left them vulnerable to be manipulated, whose fault is that? If you are not ready to acknowledge that, then you have no hope. The Bengalis first took the election route to make their point and you guys responded by shelling Dhaka university with 155mm artillary.

If you and your ilk have an ounce of shame and self-respect, you will stop obfuscating, deflecting and finding excuses and acknowledge that fact. You do not have a leg to stand on. You impress no one with all this creative spinning. It is a pig dude and no amount of liptick will change the fact.

After you acknowledge that, we can start talking about other stuff.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#282 Posted by swapnavasavdutta on June 19, 2009 7:03:57 am
goldfinger, the hard part for you to understand and
absorb may be, hinjew ab hinjew nahi rahe, they have
imbibed some after interacting with brutal Muslims
military invader and civilian dictator and brutes
like Jinnah, and are dishing out to you guys.
You had monopoly on this for past 1300 years,
no more, good or bad, mostly bad for you guys.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
listing 1-16   1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11

Interact Index

    #297 meenug
    #296 vakibs
    #295 RanaRajputana
    #294 foggy1
    #293 foggy1
    #292 bhs75
    #291 echoboom
    #290 saab900s
    #289 CoolAL
    #288 major
    #287 pinku
    #286 Goldfinger
    #285 GT
    #284 kaurasach
    #283 CoolAL
    #282 swapnavasavdutta
    #281 major
    #280 major
    #279 Goldfinger
    #278 swapnavasavdutta
    #277 Goldfinger
    #276 major
    #275 major
    #274 Goldfinger
    #273 Goldfinger
    #272 harish_hyd
    #271 harish_hyd
    #270 swapnavasavdutta
    #269 Goldfinger
    #268 bulleya
    #267 Goldfinger
    #266 nkg
    #265 nkg
    #264 nkg
    #263 tahir
    #262 VRV
    #261 major
    #260 swapnavasavdutta
    #259 VRV
    #258 major
    #257 swapnavasavdutta
    #256 major
    #255 Fouz
    #254 harish_hyd
    #253 harish_hyd
    #252 Goldfinger
    #251 tahir
    #250 harish_hyd
    #249 Goldfinger
    #248 harish_hyd
    #247 Goldfinger
    #246 RiazHaq
    #245 Regards
    #244 Kulharee
    #243 fullyautomatix
    #242 laddu
    #241 laddu
    #240 laddu
    #239 laddu
    #238 laddu
    #237 khamkhwa
    #236 Regards
    #235 VRV
    #234 major
    #233 RiazHaq
    #232 echoboom
    #231 RiazHaq
    #230 dost_mittar
    #229 RiazHaq
    #228 RiazHaq
    #227 dost_mittar
    #226 VRV
    #225 tahmed32
    #224 banjara286
    #223 Goldfinger
    #222 major
    #221 Goldfinger
    #220 major
    #219 Goldfinger
    #218 Goldfinger
    #217 Regards
    #216 dude40000
    #215 Regards
    #214 swapnavasavdutta
    #213 major
    #212 laddu
    #211 laddu
    #210 RiazHaq
    #209 major
    #208 laddu
    #207 masadi
    #206 masadi
    #205 tahmed32
    #204 masadi
    #203 RiazHaq
    #202 VRV
    #201 RiazHaq
    #200 Regards
    #199 VRV
    #198 VRV
    #197 laddu
    #196 RiazHaq
    #195 laddu
    #194 CoolAL
    #193 VRV
    #192 VRV
    #191 laddu
    #190 RiazHaq
    #189 laddu
    #188 laddu
    #187 laddu
    #186 laddu
    #185 VRV
    #184 laddu
    #183 RiazHaq
    #182 laddu
    #181 laddu
    #180 laddu
    #179 laddu
    #178 VRV
    #177 VRV
    #176 Goldfinger
    #175 RiazHaq
    #174 major
    #173 major
    #172 Goldfinger
    #171 nkg
    #170 harish_hyd
    #169 BJ2
    #168 nkg
    #167 BJ2
    #166 Goldfinger
    #165 Goldfinger
    #164 nkg
    #163 nkg
    #162 harish_hyd
    #161 Goldfinger
    #160 Goldfinger
    #159 Goldfinger
    #158 Goldfinger
    #157 nkg
    #156 ahmedmadani
    #155 ahmedmadani
    #154 Cobra
    #153 pinku
    #152 Cobra
    #151 Cobra
    #150 ahmedmadani
    #149 pinku
    #148 nkg
    #147 nkg
    #146 nkg
    #145 harish_hyd
    #144 pinku
    #143 nkg
    #142 masadi
    #141 Salim_Chauhan
    #140 Goldfinger
    #139 RiazHaq
    #138 giani_240
    #137 giani_240
    #136 masadi
    #135 RiazHaq
    #134 masadi
    #133 shankar
    #132 giani_240
    #131 giani_240
    #130 giani_240
    #129 giani_240
    #128 CoolAL
    #127 malikrashid
    #126 tahmed32
    #125 masadi
    #124 malikrashid
    #123 masadi
    #122 tahmed32
    #121 tahmed32
    #120 masadi
    #119 masadi
    #118 tahmed32
    #117 masadi
    #116 masadi
    #115 masadi
    #114 masadi
    #113 giani_240
    #112 RiazHaq
    #111 RiazHaq
    #110 giani_240
    #109 RiazHaq
    #108 malikrashid
    #107 giani_240
    #106 giani_240
    #105 TehsinA
    #104 TehsinA
    #103 malikrashid
    #102 giani_240
    #101 masadi
    #100 masadi
    #99 pmishra2
    #98 masadi
    #97 giani_240
    #96 vengatramanan
    #95 giani_240
    #94 giani_240
    #93 giani_240
    #92 giani_240
    #91 giani_240
    #90 Cobra
    #89 Cobra
    #88 Cobra
    #87 RiazHaq
    #86 Cobra
    #85 NangaPir
    #84 Goldfinger
    #83 Goldfinger
    #82 RiazHaq
    #81 Cobra
    #80 pmishra2
    #79 nkg
    #78 nkg
    #77 krbhatti
    #76 Goldfinger
    #75 harish_hyd
    #74 nkg
    #73 nkg
    #72 vengatramanan
    #71 pinku
    #70 Goldfinger
    #69 pinku
    #68 Goldfinger
    #67 krbhatti
    #66 harish_hyd
    #65 Cobra
    #64 pinku
    #63 majumdar
    #62 Cobra
    #61 Cobra
    #60 Goldfinger
    #59 pinku
    #58 Cobra
    #57 pinku
    #56 Cobra
    #55 vengatramanan
    #54 Cobra
    #53 malikrashid
    #52 vengatramanan
    #51 harish_hyd
    #50 Cobra
    #49 Cobra
    #48 Cobra
    #47 nkg
    #46 nkg
    #45 Cobra
    #44 ahmedmadani
    #43 Cobra
    #42 RiazHaq
    #41 Cobra
    #40 nkg
    #39 vengatramanan
    #38 nkg
    #37 RiazHaq
    #36 Cobra
    #35 masadi
    #34 nkg
    #33 anil
    #32 nkg
    #31 masadi
    #30 nkg
    #29 nkg
    #28 pmishra2
    #27 MilesToGo
    #26 dost_mittar
    #25 anil
    #24 anil
    #23 anil
    #22 RiazHaq
    #21 masadi
    #20 masadi
    #19 anil
    #18 anil
    #17 AlephNull
    #16 RiazHaq
    #15 PabloGanja
    #14 dost_mittar
    #13 jang
    #12 PabloGanja
    #11 PabloGanja
    #10 CreateAlpha
    #9 masadi
    #8 CreateAlpha
    #7 masadi
    #6 masadi
    #5 masadi
    #4 pinku
    #3 RiazHaq
    #2 Naqshbandi
    #1 akcheema

Latest Interacts

  • SittingBull: Italy Police arrest Pakistani... I Want Jinnah's Pakistan
  • SittingBull: Italy Police arrest Pakistani... I Want Jinnah's Pakistan
  • parthaab: Re: # 2 I began... Communicating Medical Errors
  • Sinha: Re: # 7 Pakistani..dimaag..amazes me..... The Jehadi Frankenstein
  • Sanatani: Bhai sahab, You want Jinnah's... I Want Jinnah's Pakistan
  • Sanatani: Re: # 9 Abe oye... Uneven Democracy : The
  • Sanatani: Re: # 7 Whether Riaz... Uneven Democracy : The
  • Sanatani: Re: # 5 Commie to... Uneven Democracy : The

THEMES

  • Pakistan's Struggle for Democracy
  • The Indian Story
  • Indo-Pak Relations
  • Personal Narratives
  • Religion Today
  • War on Terror
  • Role of Media
  • Call for Social Change
  • Hold Them Accountable
  • Environment and Us
  • Way of Life
more »

Top 5 Articles This Week

  • Popular
  • The Strange Case of the Indian Channels That Did Not Air the 26/11 Documentary
  • Why MQM Wants To Enter Punjab?
  • I Want Jinnah's Pakistan
  • Forgive n Forget
  • Three Poems by Allama Iqbal
  • Featured
  • There are a Lot of Monkeys
  • White Charade
  • Words of a Woman
  • FOX News and the Smelly Shoes
  • Dilemmas of Creative Children
  • 10 Years Ago
  • Farce
  • Our Real and Imaginary Complexes are Not Complex
  • Pagans and Competitive Conversions
  • Liberty Nites
  • Movie: Earth

Write on Chowk Interact Guidelines Privacy policy Terms Contact

Copyright © 1997 - 2009 chowk.com. All Rights Reserved
Reproduction of material on any www.chowk.com pages without prior written permissions is strictly prohibited