His Decision

The story and its premise are interesting. But I do find it sad, and think that, in many ways, it helps to confirm an anchient stereotype that gays can never live happy, fulfilled lives, within permanent relationships. I don`t think this is true, of course, and would have preferred a different ending

Re: Goga and AzizS

You both make the very valid observation that human societies are based on social and cultural orders and rules that can hardly be compared to the state in which animals exist in nature. My reason for pointing out that homosexual practices exist among other animals is solely to make the observation that since such practices exist in nature, they cannot be considered ``unnatural``. It is for humans to decide whether homosexual behaviour is acceptable within the realm of modern human societies and the ethical premises on which they are based.

Anita

Re: Kafir

You mentioned something about a Gay organization for Muslims. I would be interested to see how the religion and the lifestyle are reconciled. As with all major religions, this `sin` seems to feared nad loathed more than other ones by Muslims. However, I cannot in good faith reconcile Islam with the belief that homosexuality is all right. In my opinion you have to choose one or the other. But I would be interested to learn of other views.

Good article, though.

Faraz

re: Kafir
``Even if it is a genetic trait, I wouldn`t label it an `oddity,` but rather an aspect of human diversity.``
I absolutely agree and stand corrected. Diversity is what I meant and, in retrospect, I do realize, that `oddity` has a somewhat negative connotation. I was trying to make a distinction between psychology and genetics.

Also please don`t change your name, it would be changing your identity. Or maybe do something like `the chowkwallah formerly known as Kafir` ;-)

regards

First off. Beautiful tale. I`m just an old romantic who is easily swayed by emotional tales. But I`m sure you`ve heard enough praise (oh.. could that even exist?)

But on another hand, a couple of replies ago, someone mentioned that homosexuality existed in nature. Well I`m not too familiar with insect and other non-mammalian social groups, but in primate and some complex mammalian social groups (wolves etc) there does exist homosexual behaviour. However there are differences between that behaviour and the incidents of homosexuality in humans.

Homosexuality in primates (although I am aware that humans are primates, could we please ignore that fact as our social structure has a complexity many orders above that of the average ape or monkey?) is a byproduct of social order. The ``taking`` of one male by another is for establishment of heirarchical standing and as barter for goods or services.

Homosexuality in humans occurs maybe because of genetic influence, maybe environmental influences, maybe a mixture of both. But the fact is that it does not arise (ordinarily) for the purpose of setting a pecking order (if you will). Rare incidences of this sort of thing happening in such non-normal settings such as prison have been recorded.

So, in conclusion, the justification of homosexuality because ``hey.. it occurs in nature`` is an uninformed one. However, Hetero-, Bi- or Homo- sexuality should not be labelled ``un natural``, because human behaviour is completly ``un natural``. It is not natural to be rational thinking creatures. It is not natural to have ``morals`` or ``principles``. But since we are rational, thinking creatures, with morals and principles. I think we should think long and hard about exactly

why we should care.

who sticks what.. where.

(couldn`t resist the crudity of that remark)

Thank you.

AzizS

Kafir:

Changing names would be like building a new identity. Why not leave it as it is. I am one for reading the contents or message rather than who is saying it.

When I expressed or failed to convey my reservations and discomfort on this story/topic it was partly based on the uniterrupted input on the ``cultural`` intel chip we are programmed with. Also, must admit there was no need to de-programme or re-programme this chip. There is no 24hour pressure on me/us to respond to this issue. That is why when you say ``emotional disengagament and alienation becomes second nature to us`` it is cause for more serious concern. You have to rationalise it all, and constantly. Assuming an intelligence spread in the gay/lesbian community to reflect the mainstream folks, it must be tough on the majority of you.

regards

Beautifully and sensitively written. Extremely poignant. I wish people who call gays and lesbians deviant, evil and unnatural, can read this with open eyes to realize that all our thoughts, desires, passions and motivators are the same, regardless of orientation. To circumvent the risk of bursting into a soulful version of Coombaya, I will sign off. Looking forward to reading more from you.

Hi Kafir bhai n everyone,

Its a well written story with a grip on modern language and ordered in its flow. There is one thing I would like to mention, though. Once a story is finished, the writer`s job is over -his creation speaks for itself. The writer is not required to provide any missing lines or content AFTER the writing has been made, the content speaks for itself. Complete or uncomplete, the story is finished. Its an art form -its not journalism.

Omar has a guilt. A feeling of shame since his behaviour is not acceptable in the mainstream of the society. In the abscence of sexual satisfaction, he turns to religion to overcome his desire(?) and/ or shame, but there is something missing. With Oren, he finds this satisfaction and with this satisfaction, he loses his shame and finds his own community. The turning event is Orgen`s departure which brings Omar to the question - to be or not to be (gay).

What is the stimulus that triggers his urge to decide, to make a move? Abscence of Orgen? (Orgen the person or Orgen the gay partner?) Or is it the reaction of a romantic ditched by his partner? Or is it the guilt of being left alone? He does not seem to be away from his community of homosexuals. Why does Omer need to change?

Right in the beginning, he has decided to do it one last time.....with anyone....Juan. Though it seems so, but it is not Juan`s alienation, that makes him think of a change. It is the abscence of satisfaction.........the vacuum created by Orgen`s departure that triggers the mind to look for a solution. Any solution.

The story closes with a firmer note. Omar is taking an interest in religion to over come the vacuum of satisfaction. Before Orgen, religion was a replacement more for guilt than for satisfaction. After Orgen, it is solely to take refuge from his memories( in which he has tasted completeness and fulfilment) and the pain of Orgen`s abscence, that instigates his need to get into religion.

Its quite interesting, the story does not deal with the future. It deals with the present as defined by the experiences of the past. It becomes more true in life.

The Story has a lagging factor. The technique for changing sex has been presented to beleive that such a change is possible. This leads us to beleive that if a perfect mutation is made, then a satisfaction with a hetrosexual partner would be as fulfilling as with a homosexual partner. In that situation, Omar would not need a religion. Thus religion is only a transient phase before being normal. I think the writer should have created some doubt in the success of such a `scientific` technique, to keep the question of future wide open.............would Omer ever find a satisfaction as a hetro sexual ?

The setting of the story in a homosexual backgroud is a vivid example of the writer`s understanding of this environment. But beyond this horizon, the story also expands to cover the complexity called love.

On a lighter note, when a relationship (love) between two people breaks, the one to leave is called a realist, and the one left sulking is called a romantic........

Excellent effort Kafir, keep it up.......and I hope u do diversify to write on in other background themes.

jamshed nazar.

PS. there was no need to specify that though omer made a decision, kafir(the writer) has not. this triggers the reader to believe that its more a memoir than a short story. Thats how most commenters are equating kafir = omer. Its needless, and specially right after the ending climax!

Hello everyone,

I`ve been away from Chowk for some time, so I didn`t realize my short story had ben published until just today. Sorry for the delay in responding to your feedback. Thanks to you all for your helpful comments, questions, compliments, and criticisms.

Re: AA

The burning of effigies and mock funeral procession scene is purely fictional (unless anyone else knows of this happening). But given gay men`s penchant for melodrama, I can see it happening quite easily :).

Re: temporal

``As a hetereosexual,

I am always a little uncomfortable reading or discussing same sex tales. I cannot get into it with emotions--- sort of surgically detached, critical-analytical mode. And sans emotion, the enjoyment lacks something.``

Good observation. Now you understand how gay people feel when they are constantly bombarded with images of heterosexual love and relationships in their families, in the media, in schools and universities, and in their workplaces. Emotional disengagement and alientaion become second nature to us.

``what if the screen lovemaking was done by Shah Rukh Khan and Akshay Khanna? Do you think our reactions would have been different?``

Oh please, don`t tease me like that! :) Seriously, though, I think the reaction would probably have been different. Given the patriarchal nature of Indian/desi society and the appropriation of female sexuality solely for male pleasure, the reaction to a gay male love affair would been less severe since it wouldn`t have threatened male power or made male sexuality irrelevant to women. Also, the lesbian realtionship in Fire seemed to stem more from societal and familial circumstances than from an inherent, exclusive attraction to the same sex. It was more of a commentary on the position and power/powerlessnessof women in Indian society than a study of homosexuality. Perhpas that is why it angered so many people.

Re: BG

I wouldn`t personally make this decision, but coming to either decision is no easy task. I could just as easily go Omar`s way and give in to my shame, to change myself in order to fit into some conception of the ``straight path.`` My feeling when I was writing this was that the decision isn`t so clear cut. There are many valid personal reasons for either choice. I didn`t want to judge anyone who might make the decision to become straight, but I wanted to understand the reasons he might do so.

Re: Cheeno

Yes, the religious undertones do stem from my personal experiences, and I struggled a long time trying to reconcile my sexuality with my religious yearnings. At the moment, I comfortably identify as an atheist secular humanist, but who knows, that may change down the road. I`m also thinking of changing my Chowk p-nym to something more positive. `Kafir` tells others what I don`t believe, but not what I do. Any suggestions?

Re: Zehra

I`d be very happy to help you with your research. Have you heard of Al-Fatiha, the first international GLBT Muslim organization headquartered in Boston? I`ll email you with more details.

Re: RanaRansher

You`re very right in that many people, regardless of sexual orientation, gender, race, etc., face many of the same anxieties and concerns as Omar. As for the reasons why Omar wants to turn straight, the ambiguity probably arises from my inexperience as a writer in conveying Omar`s motivation and background more clearly. My idea was to use Oren as a plot device to trigger Omar`s own buried sense of shame, lack of self-worth, and loneliness which eventually lead him to his decision. The story, imo, is more about the internalized shame that develops as a result of being `different` and disliked and the self-esteem issues that arise out of it. The broken relationship is less essential. But as a reader, you`re entitled to your own opinion, of course.

As for a gay gene, none has been discovered yet, but there is strong eveidence that sexual orientation has a genetic and biological component, if not 100% causation. Even if it is a genetic trait, I wouldn`t label it an `oddity,` but rather an aspect of human diversity. For instance, left-handed people are not `odd`; they`re simply different. Psychology and upbringing also may play a role to a certain extent, but the depression and alienation that many gays suffer from result not from any inherent psychological problem, but from society`s inability to accept them as they are.

Re: OMAR1974

It`s not easy talking about my relationship with my somewhat estranged family, so I hope you don`t mind if I refrain from a Jerry Springeresque testimonial. Suffice it to say that`s it`s a VERY touchy issue, cloaked in shame, disappointment, anger, and fear on both sides. Sexuality in general is hardly discussed in our familes and culture, and family duty is paramount, so my deciding to come out and live an openly gay life has ruptured a lot of the fabric of my family. But I have to live may life honestly. Others may decide to sacrifice personal happiness and fulfilment for their families, and I respect that decision as well. To each his own...

Re: Anita

I sincerely hope that people don`t begin to view homosexuality as a disease again. In fact, many gay activists are opposed to the biological search for sexual orientation for precisely this reason. But, imo, finding such a causation would be a positive thing. Gays and lesbians have always said that their feelings and attractions were not by choice, and if biology can prove that, so much the better. The challenge lies in convincing straight people that being gay is like being tall, or being left-handed, or being male, or being fair-skinned - simply another value-neutral character trait. It`s a tough challenge, considering all the religious and cultural taboos associated with sexuality, but it can be done (and is being done in liberal circle s throughout the Western world).

Re: FerozK, SR, HijabMan, Wasiq, and everyone

Thanks for your kind and encouraging words. It`s very heartening to find supportive friends in the Pakistani/desi community from which I have become estranged to a large degree.

BTW, the reply #16 from `Kafir` is not from me. Must be some glitch in the response processing. It should belong as reply #83 under another article. Waheed I am not! :)

Uh,... editors, I think you mixed up my reply with someone else`s. The previous reply by ``Kafir`` is not by me!

Kafir

Post #83 in the Discovering ALi Hassan article and Post #16 are almost identical. Shall we read something into it?

Re: Fozia

My heart goes out to your story...please send your latest picture in a self addressed envelope to me c/o chowk staff...ASAP !!! I would really like to help.

P.S. Faraz/Omar/temp/Feroze, a friend of mine has a saying, which goes something like this, ``its the same damn thing all the way, in one case you end up paying a lump sum at the begining and in the other you just make it into installments over a period of time, and then his favorite word but ``$%

sorry, but i must say, that was abolutely brilliant. (confession: i hate when authors leave it open ended like that hahaha..i have to know what happened...but i think ill just let my imagination do the work) ...i like the style of writing. Very detailed, vivid, put a picture in my head..the GAY gene and HET gene :) loved it, and love that u can openly talk about homosexuality when so many people will start throwing around insults....thanks

Javed

re: Anita
Thanks for clearing that up.

Anita and others:

Incest and killing the offspring are common practices in the animal kingdom. But that does not justify for human being to do the same. Humans can do better than being ruled by their whims and lusts. Shaar irshad hay:

janvaron se behtar hay insan banena

magar es may lagtee hay mehnat zayada

(Sorry, Allama Sahib)

Nicely done, Kafir. The HET-1 gene injection as a `cure` really got me thinking. What if?

How would people react - gay and straight? Would we start thinking of homosexuality as a disease again? Would we advise treatment? Enforce it?

Would have liked to know more about why Omar wanted to become straight? Was it purely a reaction to his lover`s leaving?

Re: RanaRansher

Don`t know if this will help, but homosexuality is a common practice in nature, from insects to lower mammals, to intelligent primates (macaques, baboons, chimps etc). It isn`t a practice unique to humans. Psychiatrists no longer regard it as a disease, although a couple of decades ago, they did. It is now considered within the spectrum of normal human behavior. There is almost certainly a genetic predisposition, with genetic expression depending on the environment and early sexual experiences of the child.

A