Beena Sarwar October 16, 2002
#1 Posted by Ras on October 16, 2002 10:01:24 am
Thank you very much for this piece Beena Sarwar.
People like Sobho Gianchandani are that rare gift that our often myopic society fails to cherish.
Ras Siddiqui
#2 Posted by Tipu on October 16, 2002 10:28:19 am
=== Interact Filtered ===
view this users filtered interacts
view this users filtered interacts
#3 Posted by Saminasha on October 16, 2002 10:28:19 am
Thanks for this moving profile.
Is Gianchandani affiliated with any organisations that include/mentor younger activists?
Is Gianchandani affiliated with any organisations that include/mentor younger activists?
#4 Posted by temporal on October 16, 2002 12:09:10 pm
Tipu # 3:
you may have read it in the News or the Dawn or more likely here in one of the interacts...think i may have posted this...
..t
you may have read it in the News or the Dawn or more likely here in one of the interacts...think i may have posted this...
..t
#7 Posted by nooralain on October 16, 2002 12:09:10 pm
good piece. hope he`s been an inspiration in Sindh, as well as the rest of Pakistan. agree with Ras.
#8 Posted by Prem on October 16, 2002 1:35:42 pm
Yes, read this before somewhere. An inspirational tale.
#9 Posted by SameerJB on October 16, 2002 4:26:24 pm
Thanks Bina Sarwar for introducing a Pakistani who can proudly walk upright for his convictions. He deserves official recognition as a freedom fighter before it is too late.
#12 Posted by jay on October 17, 2002 7:49:53 am
SENSE OF TIMING,
When the jihadists are surrounding islamabad, when the children who learned to identify hindus as part of the curriculum dominate the politics and the military, here is an article about a hindu in pakistan with an ideology that there is no god, a theory that religion is the opiate of the masses.
When the events outside are overwhelming, beena has fallen into regression of irrelevance. When the women in the streets of islamabad are harassed not dressing per the book, here is the story of a man shedding tears for old books. At this rate beena might even write an article on lala lajpat roy and ask for his house to be declared a paki heritage.
When the jihadists are surrounding islamabad, when the children who learned to identify hindus as part of the curriculum dominate the politics and the military, here is an article about a hindu in pakistan with an ideology that there is no god, a theory that religion is the opiate of the masses.
When the events outside are overwhelming, beena has fallen into regression of irrelevance. When the women in the streets of islamabad are harassed not dressing per the book, here is the story of a man shedding tears for old books. At this rate beena might even write an article on lala lajpat roy and ask for his house to be declared a paki heritage.
#13 Posted by LadyAna on October 18, 2002 8:13:40 pm
>> here is the story of a man shedding tears for old books
Yes, they were rare old books. If u had a library full of your beloved books, you`d shed tears for them too.
Yes, they were rare old books. If u had a library full of your beloved books, you`d shed tears for them too.
#14 Posted by hossp on October 19, 2002 8:38:36 pm
I have heard about Sobho a lot during my college and university days in Sindh, Pakistan. I also met him during the 70s at his home in Larkana. At that time I used to work with Jam Saqi,Mir Thebo and other members of the communist Party in Sindh. He was alegend then. I was good to know that still alive and true to idealogy. There are very few like him left in Pakistan now. One of the leader of the communist Party Imam Ali Nazish Passed away several years ago. Have not heard much about Jamal Naqvi in a long time. Can some body let us know what he is doing now a days? I know Jam Saqi is pretty much retired now. These guys have given a lot to sindh. I hope the people would remembe their scarificies for democracy in Pakistan.
#15 Posted by Pakfin on October 22, 2002 8:50:02 am
Unfortunately the powers that be are always biased and have their own views about patriotism. Patriotism is not dependant upon ethnicity or religion but is solely dependant upon nationality.
Interact Index
Also by Beena Sarwar
Similar Articles
- The Gin Game Naveen Qayyum
- The Unbearable Lightness of Seeing Wajahat Malik
- Yet Another Immigrant Story Madiha Qureshi
- Solving Amarnath: A New Hope in Kashmir Murtaza Shibli
- Diabetes: Wrestling with a Twenty-First Century Monster Mutaal Mooquin
US Elections 2008 Primaries
Latest Interacts
- Eklavya: yeah mohar, but hamidm... Muslim Ghettoisation
- mohar11: Re: # 172 hamid well,... Muslim Ghettoisation
- mohar11: Re: # 172 hamid well,... Muslim Ghettoisation
- mohar11: Re: # 172 hamid well,... Muslim Ghettoisation
- mike195879: It is a... Yet Another Immigrant Story
- akcheema: I am still at... Muslim Ghettoisation
- quin: Re: # 43 Your... Diabetes: Wrestling with a
- mike195879: Tahmed: Thanks ... Muslim Ghettoisation








reply to this interact
write a new interact
add to favorites
flag objectionable content