Aamir Ansari January 11, 2003
#1 Posted by Harpreet on January 12, 2003 6:47:04 am
Oh man
I can just picture these gems coming to you as you observe the world surrounding you, as you watch the patients at your practice, as you read a book and wonder at the mystery of literary engagement, as you see your children, or nieces or nephews rising in the morning.
You transmute life into art.
-h-
#2 Posted by FarzanaVersey on January 12, 2003 11:55:41 am
(Am not sure if this went through earlier)
A: I think Harpreet has said it...but could it also be that it is your art keeping life `alive`?
Having said this, although I like most of the images, I am beginning to fear that technique could at some stage overtake raw emotion. It is not likely to happen soon. Or perhaps, you like to think over your emotions...
I have begun to see you as Chowk`s resident poet anyway :) The other one is a lazy bum...
Farzana
A: I think Harpreet has said it...but could it also be that it is your art keeping life `alive`?
Having said this, although I like most of the images, I am beginning to fear that technique could at some stage overtake raw emotion. It is not likely to happen soon. Or perhaps, you like to think over your emotions...
I have begun to see you as Chowk`s resident poet anyway :) The other one is a lazy bum...
Farzana
#3 Posted by ana_dobarah on January 12, 2003 1:54:17 pm
Really nice..aamir.
Farzoo..
re `the other one is a lazy bum...` hai hai!!! *laugh*
Farzoo..
re `the other one is a lazy bum...` hai hai!!! *laugh*
#4 Posted by semipreciousme on January 12, 2003 1:59:00 pm
....as always...beautiful yet tangible....
#5 Posted by Saminasha on January 12, 2003 2:59:48 pm
``...The night is no longer a silent prayer
But the inside of a shoe, turning around ..``
Excellent.
#7 Posted by nasah on January 12, 2003 8:05:06 pm
Aamir mian -- masterfully hidden snapshot of the night duty of a poor Intern -- doing Pediatric rotations -- whose ``night is no longer a silent prayer/but the inside of a shoe turning around/Backward into dawn``.... bravo .. what a way to express the night...!!!
don`t worry Aamir miaN -- u will soon -- under your residency -- turn around the night of ur interns like the inside of a shoe -- soon:-)
don`t worry Aamir miaN -- u will soon -- under your residency -- turn around the night of ur interns like the inside of a shoe -- soon:-)
#9 Posted by FarzanaVersey on January 12, 2003 11:55:50 pm
Harpreet:
[Some things are beyond technique]
That is precisely my point. I talked about raw emotion being overtaken by technique, which I see as quite distinct from form. A sonnet can be awash with feeling. It is just that sometimes are used like a hammer where a chisel would work better...it is certainly not about this poem...but to me poetry has to perforce contain an element of vulnerability. Or am I being naive?
Btw, this has nothing to do with Aamir, who does have a heart :)
[Some things are beyond technique]
That is precisely my point. I talked about raw emotion being overtaken by technique, which I see as quite distinct from form. A sonnet can be awash with feeling. It is just that sometimes are used like a hammer where a chisel would work better...it is certainly not about this poem...but to me poetry has to perforce contain an element of vulnerability. Or am I being naive?
Btw, this has nothing to do with Aamir, who does have a heart :)
#10 Posted by Harpreet on January 13, 2003 3:33:12 am
Farzana
{{but to me poetry has to perforce contain an element of vulnerability. Or am I being naive? }}
- I think all writing has many functions and availabilities to the reader, I dont think you are being naive, in fact I think that implicit in the very nature of poetry is the vulnerability of appraisal and display. After all, the poet renders his/her emotions, insight and observations into words, and explicitly or subliminally puts it forward for consumption and display.
I think good poetry is the succesful handling of the oblique with the explicit, the metaphor with the literal, the symbol with the concrete. It is tricky and if it fails, it fails dreadfully. This poet pulls it off. I think Aamir has a nuanced and innate poetic sensibility. He is the real thing.
Aamir
Is it really about a medical intern on night shift?
I read it as a father observing his children rising from their slumber, putting on their shoes, getting ready for school.
Which is good, because everybody reads it differently I suppose.
-h-
#11 Posted by temporal on January 13, 2003 8:04:56 pm
aamir
don`t have any meaningful thing to add...just dropped in to say...keep sharing...also....keep posting the poems on the unplugged thread...
the night, having coaxed the last of the light
succumbs
to the light of dawn
...t
don`t have any meaningful thing to add...just dropped in to say...keep sharing...also....keep posting the poems on the unplugged thread...
the night, having coaxed the last of the light
succumbs
to the light of dawn
...t
#12 Posted by rsridhar on January 14, 2003 10:37:37 am
re: the poem
Good one, Aamir. Keep it up. No one will tell you this, but there is much merit in brevity. Keep your poems and thoughts brief, just like this one. Let others wonder what you really meant. Your poems evoke a picture. Is it about the Pediatric Internship in US as some people are suggeting? If so, my sympathies. I know what it is like. As Americans would say, been there, done that.
Sridhar
Good one, Aamir. Keep it up. No one will tell you this, but there is much merit in brevity. Keep your poems and thoughts brief, just like this one. Let others wonder what you really meant. Your poems evoke a picture. Is it about the Pediatric Internship in US as some people are suggeting? If so, my sympathies. I know what it is like. As Americans would say, been there, done that.
Sridhar
#13 Posted by Ansari on January 15, 2003 1:13:02 am
Ana, semipreciousme, Samina Shah, Siddiqui sahab, Sridhar-jee; glad you liked the poem! thank you.
Farzana; *hic* (ek tau ye hichkiyan pata nahin kahan se lag gaee hain) bohat shukriya aap ki himmat afzai ka. :)
Harpreet, Hasan sahab; when I wrote the poem it was just a memory of watching my younger brother/cousins getting up in the morning.
Hasan sahab, mein tau samajhta tha ke main ne is poem ko khud raat ke andhere mein se dhoondha tha; mujhe kya pata tha ke iski saheli bhi waheen chuppi thi, saiyyon mein muskurati hui. aapka shukriya humein milane ka!
Harpreet, thanks for the kind words, jigar! Not entirely convinced I`m as good as you think I am (had to look up ``transmute`` in the dictionary) but truly pleased that you like my work.
Aamir
Farzana; *hic* (ek tau ye hichkiyan pata nahin kahan se lag gaee hain) bohat shukriya aap ki himmat afzai ka. :)
Harpreet, Hasan sahab; when I wrote the poem it was just a memory of watching my younger brother/cousins getting up in the morning.
Hasan sahab, mein tau samajhta tha ke main ne is poem ko khud raat ke andhere mein se dhoondha tha; mujhe kya pata tha ke iski saheli bhi waheen chuppi thi, saiyyon mein muskurati hui. aapka shukriya humein milane ka!
Harpreet, thanks for the kind words, jigar! Not entirely convinced I`m as good as you think I am (had to look up ``transmute`` in the dictionary) but truly pleased that you like my work.
Aamir
#15 Posted by Bhains on January 27, 2003 9:31:25 am
it seems that you love eliot... i do too.....but i try not to write like him, which is hard to do
Shabbo Shabbo
Shabbo Shabbo
Interact Index
Similar Articles
- Greek Tragedy Emma Alam
- US Commando Strike in Waziristan Agha Amin
- Bihar & Louisiana: A Poem Mutaal Mooquin
- There is no ‘honour’ in killing Beena Sarwar
- Why Zardari Should Be President! Ather Naqvi
US Elections 2008 Primaries
Latest Interacts
- ahmedmadani: Re: # 61 Major... US Commando Strike in
- MatloobZaman: Re: # 39 by... There is no ‘honour’
- Ravi_Kopra: Interesting! paani paani har jagah tum... Bihar & Louisiana: A
- pavocavalry: in logon main itna... US Commando Strike in
- pavocavalry: it is fiction to... US Commando Strike in
- ahmedmadani: Kayani telling Americans silently... US Commando Strike in
- nkg: Re: # 40 Majumder.... Sikhs have... US Commando Strike in
- quin: Re: # 2 MatloobZaman, Thank... Honor Killings in Babakot








reply to this interact
write a new interact
add to favorites
flag objectionable content