A Bismil May 18, 2005
#4 Posted by anokhi on May 18, 2005 11:04:28 am
pity how only a john could love her for who she was...on second thoughts, johns are pretty cute ;)
good for fauzia!
good for fauzia!
#5 Posted by Saminasha on May 18, 2005 11:12:41 am
Anokhi,
It would be nice to read about those rare progressive desi single men, their mas and aunties who could care less about the circus and nonsense around lookism...
It would be nice to read about those rare progressive desi single men, their mas and aunties who could care less about the circus and nonsense around lookism...
#6 Posted by terranova on May 18, 2005 11:36:30 am
how come every act of freedom by a ``desi`` woman involves running out into the world and sleeping around?
or maybe that`s just a metaphor women use and that a regressive desi single man like me cannot understand.
and you should also realize the ``mas and aunties`` are themselves women and encourage this behaviour.. ``saas bhi kabhi bahu thi``
or maybe that`s just a metaphor women use and that a regressive desi single man like me cannot understand.
and you should also realize the ``mas and aunties`` are themselves women and encourage this behaviour.. ``saas bhi kabhi bahu thi``
#7 Posted by miriamk on May 18, 2005 11:38:30 am
You have insightfully captured the pathology ailing the desi community when it comes to the choosing of mates (especially from the perspective of those who aren’t willing to sacrifice themselves at the altar of matrimony). And you have done it with subtlety to boot (well, maybe not so subtle in some places ;)). A great read!
#89 Posted by sajal on May 19, 2005 7:36:51 am
Re: # 8
Miss Sha,
That is absolutely right!! female empowerment!!!!!
Miss Sha,
That is absolutely right!! female empowerment!!!!!
#8 Posted by Saminasha on May 18, 2005 11:46:54 am
Terranova,
What you ``brothas`` dont seem to understand is that a woman`s self determination over her body (reproduction, physical labor, strength gained during practicing sport, martial arts, dancing, etc., ability towards combat, AND sexual pleasure) is a significant as her intellectual development. Controlling and patriarchical language blows the stench of bs over this very obvious and powerful reality.
What you ``brothas`` dont seem to understand is that a woman`s self determination over her body (reproduction, physical labor, strength gained during practicing sport, martial arts, dancing, etc., ability towards combat, AND sexual pleasure) is a significant as her intellectual development. Controlling and patriarchical language blows the stench of bs over this very obvious and powerful reality.
#9 Posted by terranova on May 18, 2005 12:14:51 pm
So rather than even try to change her society, she runs out on the situation. Stories like this do not encourage people to face reality but rather how to avoid it.
And before you jump all over me thinking that I`m just mad the character went off with a gora: I really couldn`t care. It`s not the act, but the reason that is usually given that I get annoyed at.
It seems the ultimate justification is that ``oh well, pakistani men are jerks``
And before you jump all over me thinking that I`m just mad the character went off with a gora: I really couldn`t care. It`s not the act, but the reason that is usually given that I get annoyed at.
It seems the ultimate justification is that ``oh well, pakistani men are jerks``
#10 Posted by hush on May 18, 2005 12:37:52 pm
Good one!
It truly shows the color of our culture in this aspect but I believe that slowly and gradually the numbers are changing.
My mom tells me that some of the aunties are so pathetic in this regard that even if they don`t have a son they go out to see girls. ``Bus nazar main rakhlen larki..rishta tu chayye he hota hey aksar``
It truly shows the color of our culture in this aspect but I believe that slowly and gradually the numbers are changing.
My mom tells me that some of the aunties are so pathetic in this regard that even if they don`t have a son they go out to see girls. ``Bus nazar main rakhlen larki..rishta tu chayye he hota hey aksar``
#97 Posted by urbashi on May 19, 2005 9:02:56 am
Re: # 11
I think you`re thinking of Bharati Mukherjee`s short story ``The Wife``.
I think you`re thinking of Bharati Mukherjee`s short story ``The Wife``.
#11 Posted by jang on May 18, 2005 12:47:33 pm
very fast..
the begining reminded me of a gita mehta short-story (i forget which one..amrita? the one in which a gujju woman is in NY and her husband visits).
arranged marriages should be illegal..
the begining reminded me of a gita mehta short-story (i forget which one..amrita? the one in which a gujju woman is in NY and her husband visits).
arranged marriages should be illegal..
#12 Posted by kabuliwallah on May 18, 2005 1:02:22 pm
While the situation described here does occur, is it always the men who are jerks? Don`t desi women want partners who are settled abroad, with a big bank balance, big house and a great car? Are you saying women (especially the desi variety) aren`t superficial? I agree with the author in that desis should go after Johns and Janes. Janes are hardworking, usually have a career and moreover, make an effort to stay attractive instead of letting go.
#13 Posted by miriamk on May 18, 2005 1:04:35 pm
Ms. Sha:
Re: #8
Nicely said, really. The wholistic view of a woman you outline is appealing.
Re: #5
These ``rare progressive desi single men``…where are they? I’m not being facetious at the expense of our desi men many of whom I respect and admire. But honestly, doesn’t it seem that for the most part the progressive desi man is proving to be an elusive myth?
I mean there are desi men who consider themselves progressive (and would take great offense at being thought of as otherwise) but there always seems to be a road block. And doesn`t being ``progressive`` imply continuously moving forward and embracing new ideas and thoughts....? A little disheartening really :).
Re: #8
Nicely said, really. The wholistic view of a woman you outline is appealing.
Re: #5
These ``rare progressive desi single men``…where are they? I’m not being facetious at the expense of our desi men many of whom I respect and admire. But honestly, doesn’t it seem that for the most part the progressive desi man is proving to be an elusive myth?
I mean there are desi men who consider themselves progressive (and would take great offense at being thought of as otherwise) but there always seems to be a road block. And doesn`t being ``progressive`` imply continuously moving forward and embracing new ideas and thoughts....? A little disheartening really :).
#14 Posted by Saminasha on May 18, 2005 1:06:06 pm
Terranova,
Please suggest how Fauzia might ``change`` her society. Also include examples of how you change your society.
Secondly, this particular society is constantly congratulating itself on its patriarchical values and how they are ``superior`` to the other cultural values.
Thirdly, part of a woman`s self determination is her ABSOLUTE right to choose where she will nuture herself. I guess thats what so frightening to some....
Please suggest how Fauzia might ``change`` her society. Also include examples of how you change your society.
Secondly, this particular society is constantly congratulating itself on its patriarchical values and how they are ``superior`` to the other cultural values.
Thirdly, part of a woman`s self determination is her ABSOLUTE right to choose where she will nuture herself. I guess thats what so frightening to some....
Interact Index
Latest Interacts
- majumdar: Sadna, I think I have... Living Gandhi and King
- majumdar: Sadna/YLH, My head is spinning... Living Gandhi and King
- sadna: majumdar You have to explain... Living Gandhi and King
- harish_hyd: #186 by majumdar Pakistan of... Living Gandhi and King
- sadna: What Mantolives is explaining... Living Gandhi and King
- MantoLives: Majumdar, These arguments by sadna... Living Gandhi and King
- majumdar: Sadna, Why did MKG have... Living Gandhi and King
- MantoLives: PS: Sadna's deliberate dishonesty... Living Gandhi and King








reply to this interact
write a new interact
add to favorites
flag objectionable content