Temporal May 9, 2005
#19 Posted by jang on May 10, 2005 12:29:09 pm
#17 by amrita
masses (people) of hiroshima were living under an antiquated imperialistic, casteist neo-samurai system, under which the elite ruled ruthlessly over proles who worked very hard with little say, and commited and occasional sepukku out of visions of grandeur. now (whosever survived unmaimed) lives free. not to mention rest of asia was relived of the rising-sun empire.
masses (people) of hiroshima were living under an antiquated imperialistic, casteist neo-samurai system, under which the elite ruled ruthlessly over proles who worked very hard with little say, and commited and occasional sepukku out of visions of grandeur. now (whosever survived unmaimed) lives free. not to mention rest of asia was relived of the rising-sun empire.
#18 Posted by temporal on May 10, 2005 10:06:25 am
harish_hyd #5: and drlokraj # 8:
thanks
hamidm2 # 9:
..... the middlle east and the larger islamic world has to be cleansed and suicide bombers and civilian casualties are a small price to pay in order to secure the future of mankind ....
this is another twist on white man`s burden?... an impossibly hard sell in today`s global world...
... as long as aberrations like saudi arabia, syria and iran remain this will go on .......... america must stay the course, even if it takes fity years - this is not any different than the struggle against communism ........ freedom comes at a cost .........
...freedom? what freedom?...it is all slavery and subjugation by another name...like calling interest mark-up in so called islamic banking...
...i do not think on an esoteric level anyone is free...there is no absolute freedom...having said that...the limited freedom that is available in the west needs to be applauded and its absence in the thrid world deplored...
...and any criticism of the US should be mixed with applause too...only in the US the Zinns, Chomskys and Ekbal Ahmeds can freely speak their mind and not be silenced...only in the US abdul-hates can utter their says and survive!
...relative saftey and economic progress can be provided the populace in direct absence of the touted freedoms...paging exhibit A...China!
rgds
t
thanks
hamidm2 # 9:
..... the middlle east and the larger islamic world has to be cleansed and suicide bombers and civilian casualties are a small price to pay in order to secure the future of mankind ....
this is another twist on white man`s burden?... an impossibly hard sell in today`s global world...
... as long as aberrations like saudi arabia, syria and iran remain this will go on .......... america must stay the course, even if it takes fity years - this is not any different than the struggle against communism ........ freedom comes at a cost .........
...freedom? what freedom?...it is all slavery and subjugation by another name...like calling interest mark-up in so called islamic banking...
...i do not think on an esoteric level anyone is free...there is no absolute freedom...having said that...the limited freedom that is available in the west needs to be applauded and its absence in the thrid world deplored...
...and any criticism of the US should be mixed with applause too...only in the US the Zinns, Chomskys and Ekbal Ahmeds can freely speak their mind and not be silenced...only in the US abdul-hates can utter their says and survive!
...relative saftey and economic progress can be provided the populace in direct absence of the touted freedoms...paging exhibit A...China!
rgds
t
#16 Posted by temporal on May 10, 2005 8:33:19 am
ozerkhalid #4:
But are US intransigence and Osama`s arrogance not two sides of the same coin ?... Both lieutenants of lunacy....?
yes, and both of them talk to God...with mere mortals caught in their spiral...
good quote `` What difference does it make to the dead, the orphans and the homeless, whether the mad destruction is wrought under the name of totalitarianism or the Holy name of liberty or democracy?
back to my query...how can we (those relatively living in safety) take steps to reduce the misery of the innocent civilians?
rgds
t
But are US intransigence and Osama`s arrogance not two sides of the same coin ?... Both lieutenants of lunacy....?
yes, and both of them talk to God...with mere mortals caught in their spiral...
good quote `` What difference does it make to the dead, the orphans and the homeless, whether the mad destruction is wrought under the name of totalitarianism or the Holy name of liberty or democracy?
back to my query...how can we (those relatively living in safety) take steps to reduce the misery of the innocent civilians?
rgds
t
#15 Posted by jang on May 10, 2005 8:31:59 am
``You do what you do and hope to God that you dont live to wake up on a nuclear morning. ``
very interesting..hiroshima did wake up that way giving way to a forever changed japan (for the better)
very interesting..hiroshima did wake up that way giving way to a forever changed japan (for the better)
#17 Posted by amrita on May 10, 2005 8:55:35 am
Re: # 15
not the people in hiroshima who still live the consequences of that day.
not the people in hiroshima who still live the consequences of that day.
#14 Posted by amrita on May 10, 2005 8:08:12 am
t - jang said ``pehle insaan`` and I would like to say the same albeit in a slightly different context. When you wonder as a Muslim why other Muslims do something you as a Muslim see prohibited by the faith they ostensibly defend, you forget the insaaniyat of those Muslims and see them as they have presented themselves - Muslim. Period.
Insaaniyat is a positive term as used commonly, but man is not so far removed from his animal roots for all traces of it to have disappeared from his make up. A certain amount of haivaaniyat is also involved and everybody likes to justify it in diff ways. Thats why not every suicide bomber was born of Palestine.
For the rest there are no easy answers, there are no quick fixes and you know as well as I do that the blind cannot be forced to see. Its just a never ending run around the mulberry bush.
And those who see more to the issue than the bomb em, knife em, shoot em and solve it crowd [whoever or whichever religion they might be] have a longer run around their particular bush than any of the others. Its easier to kill people than live alongside them when you dont like what they have to say. If not even Gandhi or King - or if you want to take it further and religiously back, Jesus - could entirely carry the day, then what price us? You do what you do and hope to God that you dont live to wake up on a nuclear morning.
Insaaniyat is a positive term as used commonly, but man is not so far removed from his animal roots for all traces of it to have disappeared from his make up. A certain amount of haivaaniyat is also involved and everybody likes to justify it in diff ways. Thats why not every suicide bomber was born of Palestine.
For the rest there are no easy answers, there are no quick fixes and you know as well as I do that the blind cannot be forced to see. Its just a never ending run around the mulberry bush.
And those who see more to the issue than the bomb em, knife em, shoot em and solve it crowd [whoever or whichever religion they might be] have a longer run around their particular bush than any of the others. Its easier to kill people than live alongside them when you dont like what they have to say. If not even Gandhi or King - or if you want to take it further and religiously back, Jesus - could entirely carry the day, then what price us? You do what you do and hope to God that you dont live to wake up on a nuclear morning.
#13 Posted by temporal on May 10, 2005 8:05:39 am
sattar2 # 3:
...how can this cycle be contained....
this is what i hope to learn from others here...am aware there are no simple answers...but there is something (sigh) that the silent majority can do to alleviate the sufferings of the innocents everywhere...even a little...even a drop...
rgds
t
...how can this cycle be contained....
this is what i hope to learn from others here...am aware there are no simple answers...but there is something (sigh) that the silent majority can do to alleviate the sufferings of the innocents everywhere...even a little...even a drop...
rgds
t
#12 Posted by shishapa on May 10, 2005 8:05:07 am
While you can get rid of likes of GWB`s peacefully or have to endure them probably not more than 8 or 12 years, how do you get rid of OBLs?
#44 Posted by ntsyed on May 13, 2005 4:14:30 am
Re: # 12
shishapa: While you can get rid of likes of GWB`s peacefully or have to endure them probably not more than 8 or 12 years, how do you get rid of OBLs?
Very simple - live and let live!
Most N American and Europeans understand and appreciate diverse cultures. But the few, influential individuals & groups (public and private) wish for Muslims to live like the non-Muslims in terms of lifestyles - interest infested banking, unbridled commercialization via sex and violence, immorality, beards, veils, blah blah blan. The Muslims were doing just fine until the former colonial masters started using the dictators` tyranny - the very bastards they had left behind to oppress the people on their behalf - to subjugate the whole people again for the sake of resources and power.
Even now, if some wish to live in the 7th century arabia, why is it a problem for anyone who wishes to live any other era - past, present, or future? The problem starts when one tries to force a parallelogram into an square slot. The oppressed masses, not just Muslims, if you care to look around the world, had to rise up sooner or later. In a dark sort of way I think we`re fortunate to witness it so our next generations (if survived) could live in a relative peace, as is the case with every storm or confrontation.
The problem with temporal lot is that they submitted to slavery back then, and they continue to submit now. Thus you see the ``need`` to change the value system vis a vis Islam, Buddhism, Hinduism, and whatever else that doesn`t allow the tyrannical few CIAs & GWBs of the world to jeopardize the survival of the entire species for a few quick bucks. Naturally, there will be OBL - right or wrong - to counter those forces. Like the latter said in one of his recent videos, stop messing with us and you will not be messed with. I suppose temporal was comatose when that solution made the headlines.
temporal, please use your research skills to dig up the truth on 9/11, Salvadoran Option, who benefits most with the sectarian violence, why it would not be good for the US to leave Iraq and the ME altogether. I`m sure your two eyes would want to pop out of your head.
Without the proper knowledge you sound worse than a broken record of rhetorics...more like a phata baans begging only for presonal attention and nothing else.
shishapa: While you can get rid of likes of GWB`s peacefully or have to endure them probably not more than 8 or 12 years, how do you get rid of OBLs?
Very simple - live and let live!
Most N American and Europeans understand and appreciate diverse cultures. But the few, influential individuals & groups (public and private) wish for Muslims to live like the non-Muslims in terms of lifestyles - interest infested banking, unbridled commercialization via sex and violence, immorality, beards, veils, blah blah blan. The Muslims were doing just fine until the former colonial masters started using the dictators` tyranny - the very bastards they had left behind to oppress the people on their behalf - to subjugate the whole people again for the sake of resources and power.
Even now, if some wish to live in the 7th century arabia, why is it a problem for anyone who wishes to live any other era - past, present, or future? The problem starts when one tries to force a parallelogram into an square slot. The oppressed masses, not just Muslims, if you care to look around the world, had to rise up sooner or later. In a dark sort of way I think we`re fortunate to witness it so our next generations (if survived) could live in a relative peace, as is the case with every storm or confrontation.
The problem with temporal lot is that they submitted to slavery back then, and they continue to submit now. Thus you see the ``need`` to change the value system vis a vis Islam, Buddhism, Hinduism, and whatever else that doesn`t allow the tyrannical few CIAs & GWBs of the world to jeopardize the survival of the entire species for a few quick bucks. Naturally, there will be OBL - right or wrong - to counter those forces. Like the latter said in one of his recent videos, stop messing with us and you will not be messed with. I suppose temporal was comatose when that solution made the headlines.
temporal, please use your research skills to dig up the truth on 9/11, Salvadoran Option, who benefits most with the sectarian violence, why it would not be good for the US to leave Iraq and the ME altogether. I`m sure your two eyes would want to pop out of your head.
Without the proper knowledge you sound worse than a broken record of rhetorics...more like a phata baans begging only for presonal attention and nothing else.
#45 Posted by ntsyed on May 13, 2005 4:43:00 am
Re: # 44
CORRECTION:
immorality, beards, veils, blah blah blan
was meant to be: ``...immorality, shave the beards, and shed the veils, blah blah blah``
CORRECTION:
immorality, beards, veils, blah blah blan
was meant to be: ``...immorality, shave the beards, and shed the veils, blah blah blah``
#11 Posted by temporal on May 10, 2005 7:09:25 am
Urstruly #2:
you should make up your mind. Either you are with the underdog or against it. i don`t think that there is any room for neutrality left now.
:)
making up my mind?...while it is never easy i am very clear about which direction not to venture...i vehemently reject the approach of GWB and OBL...i am not with either of them...my world is not tunnel-visioned like theirs...
rgds
t
#21 Posted by Urstruly on May 10, 2005 1:07:27 pm
Re: # 11
well if you are very clear that the dog and the underdog are both wrong then what kind of answers you are looking for.
According to the laws of nature there has to be an original sin, which started it all; since you are clear, what is it?
well if you are very clear that the dog and the underdog are both wrong then what kind of answers you are looking for.
According to the laws of nature there has to be an original sin, which started it all; since you are clear, what is it?
#10 Posted by temporal on May 10, 2005 6:56:51 am
jang #1
why is any nation or people innnocent? ....why not accept some responsibility?
i never mentioned any nation being innocent...that would be sheer folly...the main thrust is innocent civvies...be they in baghdad, mosul, darfur, moscow, kashmir, bombay, delhi, karachi, quetta...
as for accepting responsibility i did mention ..``The majority of moderate Muslims are not above blame.``
rgds
t
why is any nation or people innnocent? ....why not accept some responsibility?
i never mentioned any nation being innocent...that would be sheer folly...the main thrust is innocent civvies...be they in baghdad, mosul, darfur, moscow, kashmir, bombay, delhi, karachi, quetta...
as for accepting responsibility i did mention ..``The majority of moderate Muslims are not above blame.``
rgds
t
#9 Posted by hamidm2 on May 10, 2005 5:50:30 am
temporal mian,
..... the middlle east and the larger islamic world has to be cleansed and suicide bombers and civilian casualties are a small price to pay in order to secure the future of mankind .......... as long as aberrations like saudi arabia, syria and iran remain this will go on .......... america must stay the course, even if it takes fity years - this is not any different than the struggle against communism ........ freedom comes at a cost .........
..... the middlle east and the larger islamic world has to be cleansed and suicide bombers and civilian casualties are a small price to pay in order to secure the future of mankind .......... as long as aberrations like saudi arabia, syria and iran remain this will go on .......... america must stay the course, even if it takes fity years - this is not any different than the struggle against communism ........ freedom comes at a cost .........
#43 Posted by ntsyed on May 13, 2005 3:37:25 am
Re: # 9
hamidm2:
america must stay the course, even if it takes fity years - this is not any different than the struggle against communism ........ freedom comes at a cost ........
LOL... what perverted pleasure do get by torturing the young & the restless wanna be intellectuals? Can`t you see from temporal`s essay that he`s in extreme pain?
hamidm2:
america must stay the course, even if it takes fity years - this is not any different than the struggle against communism ........ freedom comes at a cost ........
LOL... what perverted pleasure do get by torturing the young & the restless wanna be intellectuals? Can`t you see from temporal`s essay that he`s in extreme pain?
#7 Posted by drlokraj on May 10, 2005 1:42:45 am
Cross-sectionally violence from both side and the motives behind it may not appear different,but seeing this phenomenon longitudinally,America has to be blamed as the main culprit.Even Osama was ``created`` by America to use him in Aghanistan against Russia and ultimately he turned into Frakenstein.
In the sub-continent,the last use of suicide bombing was by Khalistani activists who blew the then chief minister of Punjab,Beant Singh in front of the secretariat.
In the sub-continent,the last use of suicide bombing was by Khalistani activists who blew the then chief minister of Punjab,Beant Singh in front of the secretariat.
Interact Index
Latest Interacts
- mohar11: Re: # 98 Right on...... India-Pakistan: Empathy, grief in
- Dash_Dot: Re: # 84 sabji... India-Pakistan: Empathy, grief in
- mohar11: I mean - zardari... India-Pakistan: Empathy, grief in
- Dash_Dot: Tahmed32 sabji LOL at... India-Pakistan: Empathy, grief in
- AlephNull: There's nothing particularly mysterious... India-Pakistan: Empathy, grief in
- mohar11: kaal oh, we understand it... India-Pakistan: Empathy, grief in
- mohar11: if pakis really want... India-Pakistan: Empathy, grief in
- Eklavya: mohar, Pakistanis may be... India-Pakistan: Empathy, grief in








reply to this interact
write a new interact
add to favorites
flag objectionable content