unflinching idealism ... since 1997 archivessitemapabouthelpfeedback
where paths intersect
  • Home
  • InFocus
  • Themes
  • Columns
  • Articles
  • Fiction
  • iLogs
  • Gallery
  • Unplugged
  • Writers
  • Interactors
  • Tags
Sign in | Join Chowk
web chowk
  • Article
  • Interact
  • read writer comments
  • add to favorites
  • get rss feeds
  • print
  • email this link

Who Created Pakistan?

Ranjit Hira June 26, 2005

Latest comments   flat   threaded   latest   oldest   all
listing 192-208   8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17

#70 Posted by shobig_sifar on June 28, 2005 6:42:23 am
Re: # 68 ...btw what on earth took Mr. Narendra Singh Sarila 58 long years to write the said book and expose all the concealed truth? Neik kaam mein deir kaisi? Is it really a book...or a `naama-i-aamaal` for the day of judgement?

regards
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#69 Posted by Netizen on June 28, 2005 6:41:02 am
Re: # 62 hindvi:

``by the way Dawood got no personal gain from the blasts, he was very comfortably ruling the mumbai underworld before the blasts. Thus muslims of bombay are rightly grateful to him for having sacrificed his comfort for their security``

by your argument, the day dawood dies, IMs (particularly bombay muslims) are going to face retaliation. There are no large scale riots in mumbai because of the bandobast /SRP/CRPF vans standing on guard 24 hrs at volatile spots all over mumbai. Congress has committed a mistake once they are not going to let Mulayam make a come back in mumbai. Dawood is nothing but a criminal, a enunch just like any other non-muslim mafiosi who like a leech sucks others blood. Its just another disgrace that he turned out to be an anti-national.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#68 Posted by shobig_sifar on June 28, 2005 6:38:41 am
The title of the article made me recall the agony that i went through as a kid, when i spent enldless nights unable to sleep, contemplating on how in God`s name did one man, Quaid-i-Azam, manage to build this whole big country?? What labour, what passion...where did he get all the bricks and the cement from? Ahh...sadly, a read through the article has made all that agony reprise...and now I feel bleakly perplexed again.
The writer seams to have confiscated a whole generation`s struggle for a series of events that barely encompassed a year.
Nevertheless ``What hath been done shall not be undone`` - so better let the sleeping dogs lie, and divert the course of your queries to the future rather than the past.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#67 Posted by Mike on June 28, 2005 6:35:16 am
Dear Mr.Hindvi ,

Expanding your logic on the justifcation of Mumbai Bomb Blasts and extolling the virtues of your role model Dawood Ibrahim , I hope you will be fair enough to acknowledge the greatness of Narendra Modi and the necessity for the massacre of 5000 muslims in Gujarat just to make sure there will be no more Godhras. Next time a couple of thousand muslim goons burn alive 50-60 hindu women and children anywhere in India , you now know what the response will be. And not even your boy Dawood or your mates at ISI can save you. Cheers !!
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#66 Posted by stuka on June 28, 2005 6:16:13 am
It is that mafiaso that has prevented another anti muslim pogrom in bombay after the 92-93 riots in which thousands of the indian muslims you weep for were wiped out.

``The bomb blasts showed the other player in the local game that there would be repercussions to baring the machettes. They continued to talk of muslims with hatred after the blasts but this time the disdain was replaced with fear.

the reason every body and his uncle was pulling out foetuses in gujrat was that they knew there would be no repercusions.

by the way Dawood got no personal gain from the blasts, he was very comfortably ruling the mumbai underworld before the blasts. Thus muslims of bombay are rightly grateful to him for having sacrificed his comfort for their security. ``

Hinvi:

Let me flip that argument around then. To tell Pakistan that there will be repurcussions for fukking with us in Kashmir, we should slaughter Muslims in India. After all if Indian Muslims have right to go to Pakistan ISI for help in their fight with Hindus and Indian government, then we also have the right to maaro the gaand of Muslims in India for what Pakis do to us.

You think there was never ever Muslim retaliation aginst Hindus at Mohalla level in riots in Meerut or Bhiwandi? There have been Hindu Muslim riots in India since and periodically they will continue to happen. Mostly goonda badmash types of both communities settle scores. Even in Bombay in 1992, riots started in Muslim localties in December, the Hindu retaliation started in January. So not exactly a completly one sided affair.

You can either depend on civil society in India to recognize evil as it happens, recognize the imperfections of the society and try to solve them incrementally. Or you can go to your Paki Masters like Dawood Ibrahim did and live with the repurcussions. After all if Dawood could arrange for bomb blasts in Mumbai, why could he not do it in Gujarat? Where was Hindu fear then?

Choice is yours, you are either Indian and solve problems internally...or you go to Pakistan and create the impression of being stranded Pakistanis. (like Biharis in Bangladesh)




reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#65 Posted by masanamuthu on June 28, 2005 5:32:23 am
Whoever created Pakistan (whether it`s Jinnah/Nehru/Gandhi/British) they need to be appreciated by Indians.. I think V.S.Naipaul commented that partition was a good thing to happen..

Recently, A Muslim woman in Muzaffarnagar was raped by her father-in-law. Now the jamaat (and the AIMPLB) ruled according to the personal law, she is not fit to live with her husband anymore. They say this is what sharia law dictates.. Ofcourse, incest could happen in non-Muslim families too.. But can you imagine any party / board representing Hindus at the all-India level pass judgement like this. Won`t they be ridiculed ??..

Thank Allah that we got rid of 2/3rd of such folks.. I dread to think what could have happened if they had so much political power.. The whole debate about the direction of the country would have been centred around what Mr.Muhammad did in the 7`th century and how to apply it now..
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#64 Posted by vagabond78 on June 28, 2005 1:18:32 am
Who gives a damn. They have their country and we have ours. But there`s minor matter of IMs who couldnt reconcile with the situation. Minor cos only a small minority of IMs dont think of India as their country. Even UP and Bihar, states which gave Muslim League its initial momentum during independence struggle, now have Mulayam and Laloo protecting the interests of minorities. Not to mention Kerala where Muslim league and Congress are ``natural allies`` against the Marxists.

What I mean is India has at least answered the fundamental questions on identity and the idea of nation-state. So we have a multi-enthic, multi-lingual, multi-cultural, multi-party anarchy-total chaos. Ideal receipe for disaster and disintegration for any other nation on earth, but it`s perfect for India.

What about Pakistan? Who gives a damn..

Cheers
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#63 Posted by cayenne on June 27, 2005 11:52:30 pm
For horrible hindoos who cannot visit in person, awesome pics of Tirumala-Tirupati, one of the major hindu pilgrimage sites in India.For anyone actually.Many people of other faiths too visit this site in india.It`s just a click away...............

http://www.skyscrapercity.com/showthread.php?t=229227&page=1&pp=20
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#62 Posted by hindvi on June 27, 2005 11:37:46 pm
Mr Ballu

It is that mafiaso that has prevented another anti muslim pogrom in bombay after the 92-93 riots in which thousands of the indian muslims you weep for were wiped out.

The bomb blasts showed the other player in the local game that there would be repercussions to baring the machettes. They continued to talk of muslims with hatred after the blasts but this time the disdain was replaced with fear.

the reason every body and his uncle was pulling out foetuses in gujrat was that they knew there would be no repercusions.

by the way Dawood got no personal gain from the blasts, he was very comfortably ruling the mumbai underworld before the blasts. Thus muslims of bombay are rightly grateful to him for having sacrificed his comfort for their security.

adios.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#61 Posted by cayenne on June 27, 2005 11:14:47 pm
Re: # 52

You sure it ain`t root beer?.Just kidding!!.A bottle of Kingfisher or any other brand of desi beer is available at one`s neighborhood liquor store for 54 rupees.A quarter of McDowell scotch 125/- and that`s a premium brand.Prices vary at bars/pubs and discos depending on the location and state(taxation).Pondicherry on the east coast and Goa on the west coast are tax free alcohol territories.Daman and Diu service the Gujjus, `cause Gujarat is the only alcohol free state.Liquor stores generally close at midnight and are open sundays after 1pm in many states.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#60 Posted by ballukhan on June 27, 2005 9:16:22 pm
My take at this Pakistani mafiaso called Dawood-

I would ask all those Indians who have been threatened by this Paki mafiaso to pool in their expected payoff money and give it to some ex-armymen to raise a squad of assasins to exterminate this mafiaso pest from Pakistan-

even if a group of 6-7 Indians could come together and pool in 10 lacs each all that would be sufficient to raise a group of vigilante to exterminate Dawood right in his own pureland............................
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#59 Posted by sifzal on June 27, 2005 8:46:34 pm
Re: # 33
harimau you said “Post-August-1947 events were nothing but a continuation of the British policy of consolidation of power over the subcontinent that was temporarily interrupted in 1857 and suspended indefinitely in 1858….”

Reply: You mean to say that the present land known as India did not got its independence in 1947 rather remained a British colony with British agenda…well said! So when did you got independence for you may say that after Britian it was Soviet control and now USA, I guess?

harimau: ”No, Jinnah and Pakistan would have gotten East Punjab, West Bengal and Assam and then would have either converted the Hindus there by force or expelled them. Also, Jinnah had the brilliant idea of using the Hindu population of Pakistan as hostages for good treatment of Muslims left behind In India. “

If the East Punjab, West Bengal and Assam would have become Pakistan, there would have been peaceful settlement, very few killings and Hindus would have been prosperous in Pakistan like those in Sindh, and Sikhs would have avoided operation Blue Star or 1984 mass killings. The minorities killing on mass scale only happens in India not Pakistan. When the late Pope John Paul landed in Pakistan, he kissed the land and said it is one of the few countries where minorities are protected.

harimau: “Man, what a nut case!”

Please mind your language.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#58 Posted by Ashutosh_Gandhi on June 27, 2005 5:36:56 pm
This article asks right questions. British had the policy of divide and rule otherwise they would have never controlled Indian subcontinent.
People blame Jinnah, Gandhi & Nehru but British were also equally responsible for partition.

Our history books in school may not lie but do not tell us the truth either. There is nothing outlandish about british not being responsible for partition or playing Jinnah against Congress.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#57 Posted by irfanhamid on June 27, 2005 3:36:10 pm
Re: # 27 (Charlie),

Yaar, forget that. I just read your ilog entry on the ``Statistics of flirting``. I was laughing so hard I damn near got a cramp in my stomach, specially the last sentence (I almost fell off my chair) ``Sachant qu`un homme sur 10 est homosexuel et que tous les pédés sucent, il vaut mieux s`adresser à un mec``.

Where did you find this gem?

Irfan.
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#56 Posted by harimau on June 27, 2005 3:13:38 pm
Ref dullabhatti #38

[I have no doubt in my mind that if India were to stay one piece in 1947, Muslims would have, if not totally ruled India, at least would have dictated major policies and laws. There powers in 1947 were curtailed by partition.]

If Pakistan was never separated and we had a 40% Muslim population in India, Indian Muslims would be on a plane to Mecca during Haj season! At a nice discount on the airfare subsidized by the Government of India.

Oops, that is already happening with a 15% Muslim population! I shudder to think what 40% would have brought!
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
#55 Posted by harimau on June 27, 2005 3:05:52 pm
Ref khamkhwa. #34

{[ pillage BEFORE you burn, rape BEFORE you kill. And war booty does NOT mean a booty call.]- harimau.

...harimau is right...afterall he is experienced...remember gujrat...;) }

And you fcukers set fire to the train first without pillaging it.

Tsk, tsk, tsk.... will you retards EVER learn?
reply to this interact write a new interact add to favorites flag objectionable content
listing 192-208   8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17

Interact Index

    #263 badshah
    #262 swang
    #261 gr8philosopher0
    #260 bolta_aaina
    #259 harimau
    #257 ajeya
    #256 tahmed32
    #255 tahmed32
    #254 JagdeeshGodbole
    #253 ajeya
    #252 jang
    #251 southasian
    #250 harimau
    #249 southasian
    #248 tahmed32
    #247 tahmed32
    #246 southasian
    #245 antihypochrist
    #244 JagdeeshGodbole
    #243 ajeya
    #242 southasian
    #241 jang
    #240 ajeya
    #239 Mike
    #238 ajeya
    #237 southasian
    #236 arjun_m
    #235 ajeya
    #234 arjun_m
    #233 tahmed32
    #232 ajeya
    #231 arjun_m
    #230 rsridhar
    #229 rsridhar
    #228 PewResearch
    #227 ajeya
    #226 jang
    #225 ajeya
    #224 jang
    #223 southasian
    #222 sifzal
    #221 Mike
    #220 ajeya
    #219 antihypochrist
    #218 ajeya
    #217 tahmed32
    #216 antihypochrist
    #215 tahmed32
    #214 tahmed32
    #213 ajeya
    #212 antihypochrist
    #211 Ranjit
    #210 tahmed32
    #209 antihypochrist
    #208 jang
    #207 Ranjit
    #206 Mike
    #205 tahmed32
    #204 Ranjit
    #203 Netizen
    #202 Ranjit
    #201 Ranjit
    #200 googenschlaugen
    #199 googenschlaugen
    #198 khamkhwa.
    #197 googenschlaugen
    #196 ajeya
    #195 ajeya
    #194 tahmed32
    #193 ajeya
    #192 tahmed32
    #191 ajeya
    #190 ajeya
    #189 KaalChakra
    #188 bongdongs
    #187 tahmed32
    #186 tahmed32
    #185 antihypochrist
    #184 antihypochrist
    #183 rsridhar
    #182 rsridhar
    #181 googenschlaugen
    #180 Romair
    #179 ajeya
    #178 ajeya
    #177 antihypochrist
    #176 khamkhwa.
    #175 mohar11
    #174 Ranjit
    #173 mohar11
    #172 mohar11
    #171 bongdongs
    #170 Ranjit
    #169 mohar11
    #168 bongdongs
    #167 jang
    #166 Ranjit
    #165 mohar11
    #164 mohar11
    #163 bongdongs
    #162 jang
    #161 bongdongs
    #160 jang
    #159 mohar11
    #158 Ranjit
    #157 KaalChakra
    #156 rsridhar
    #155 rsridhar
    #154 Ranjit
    #153 Netizen
    #151 rahul_capri
    #150 Netizen
    #149 khamkhwa.
    #148 bongdongs
    #147 jang
    #145 mohar11
    #144 mohar11
    #143 hindvi
    #142 rahul_capri
    #141 anil
    #140 ajeya
    #139 ajeya
    #138 hindvi
    #137 rsridhar
    #136 rsridhar
    #135 Romair
    #134 mohar11
    #133 jang
    #132 bongdongs
    #131 Mike
    #130 mohar11
    #129 bongdongs
    #128 jang
    #127 aslam644
    #126 Netizen
    #125 hindvi
    #125 arjun_m
    #124 Netizen
    #123 ferozk
    #122 cayenne
    #121 HP
    #120 ballukhan
    #119 bongdongs
    #118 AlephNull
    #117 ballukhan
    #116 Romair
    #115 ballukhan
    #114 ballukhan
    #113 ballukhan
    #112 bongdongs
    #111 khamkhwa.
    #110 khamkhwa.
    #109 Netizen
    #108 bongdongs
    #107 shishapa
    #106 HP
    #105 prk
    #104 bongdongs
    #103 aslam644
    #102 Netizen
    #101 HP
    #100 cayenne
    #99 jang
    #98 HP
    #97 cayenne
    #96 rsridhar
    #95 HP
    #94 jang
    #93 jang
    #92 hindvi
    #91 mohar11
    #90 Mike
    #89 Netizen
    #88 Mike
    #87 mohar11
    #86 HP
    #85 bongdongs
    #85 bongdongs
    #84 shishapa
    #83 mohar11
    #82 hindvi
    #81 hindvi
    #80 Netizen
    #79 khamkhwa.
    #78 HP
    #77 Netizen
    #76 prk
    #75 stuka
    #74 stuka
    #73 Mike
    #72 hindvi
    #71 mohar11
    #70 shobig_sifar
    #69 Netizen
    #68 shobig_sifar
    #67 Mike
    #66 stuka
    #65 masanamuthu
    #64 vagabond78
    #63 cayenne
    #62 hindvi
    #61 cayenne
    #60 ballukhan
    #59 sifzal
    #58 Ashutosh_Gandhi
    #57 irfanhamid
    #56 harimau
    #55 harimau
    #54 Raw_Dust
    #53 Raw_Dust
    #52 hush
    #51 Netizen
    #50 cayenne
    #49 Netizen
    #48 hush
    #47 HP
    #46 cayenne
    #45 Mike
    #44 hush
    #43 cayenne
    #42 HP
    #41 mohar11
    #40 Romair
    #39 HP
    #38 dullabhatti
    #37 cayenne
    #36 aslam644
    #35 MantoLives
    #34 khamkhwa.
    #33 harimau
    #32 Urstruly
    #31 khamkhwa.
    #30 khamkhwa.
    #29 khamkhwa.
    #28 khamkhwa.
    #27 Charlie
    #26 veeresh
    #25 delhiwala
    #24 ana
    #23 veeresh
    #22 irfanhamid
    #21 Romair
    #20 KaalChakra
    #19 temporal
    #18 nauman9
    #17 KaalChakra
    #16 harish_hyd
    #15 prk
    #14 queen_cut_paste
    #13 MantoLives
    #12 sifzal
    #11 queen_cut_paste
    #10 nazarhayatkhan
    #9 ballukhan
    #8 veeresh
    #7 queen_cut_paste
    #6 cayenne
    #5 zero_tolerance
    #4 patwari
    #3 patwari
    #2 KaalChakra
    #1 hindvi

Latest Interacts

  • nb: I didn't know that,... The Correct Turn
  • akcheema: Re: # 182; nb thanks... The Correct Turn
  • nb: Cheema, hing is asafoetida... The Correct Turn
  • akcheema: Re: # 180 yaar nb... The Correct Turn
  • nb: HP, if it was... The Correct Turn
  • akcheema: dost_mittar and hamidm sahibaan,... The Correct Turn
  • ahmedmadani: When we who write... Politics of PPP and
  • ahmedmadani: Re: # 46 Zeena... Politics of PPP and

THEMES

  • Pakistan's Struggle for Democracy
  • The Indian Story
  • Indo-Pak Relations
  • Personal Narratives
  • Religion Today
  • War on Terror
  • Role of Media
  • Call for Social Change
  • Hold Them Accountable
  • Environment and Us
  • Way of Life
more »

Top 5 Articles This Week

  • Popular
  • The Correct Turn
  • G-8: RIP?
  • Urdu News Columnists and Anchors -- should we always believe them?
  • Politics of PPP and Asif Zardari
  • Hop Aboard the Interfaith Express
  • Featured
  • There are a Lot of Monkeys
  • White Charade
  • Words of a Woman
  • FOX News and the Smelly Shoes
  • Dilemmas of Creative Children
  • 10 Years Ago
  • Samson and Delilah
  • Sins of a Freeborn
  • What Is Your Caste?
  • The Good, the Bad and the Anxiety
  • Excuse Me but Can ANP Spell Pakhtoonkhwa?

Write on Chowk Interact Guidelines Privacy policy Terms Contact

Copyright © 1997 - 2008 chowk.com. All Rights Reserved
Reproduction of material on any www.chowk.com pages without prior written permissions is strictly prohibited