Shandana Minhas November 10, 2005
#7 Posted by Saminasha on November 13, 2005 10:01:07 am
Shandana,
Interestingly enough, new studies have reported that the brains of women increase during pregnancy and motherhood, not decrease.
Also, I have plenty of intellectual women friends who could not wait to hand their wailing children to their husbands and rush off to teach, write, manage programs. A former advisor said to me once if she didnt have her graduate courses to teach at night, she`d end up strangling her boys. So...why the self doubt?
Others may congratulate you on the self deprecatory metaphors-sorry, I can`t.
Interestingly enough, new studies have reported that the brains of women increase during pregnancy and motherhood, not decrease.
Also, I have plenty of intellectual women friends who could not wait to hand their wailing children to their husbands and rush off to teach, write, manage programs. A former advisor said to me once if she didnt have her graduate courses to teach at night, she`d end up strangling her boys. So...why the self doubt?
Others may congratulate you on the self deprecatory metaphors-sorry, I can`t.
#6 Posted by Aarya on November 12, 2005 7:00:55 am
An excellent read...
Can sense it all. Very True.
Can sense it all. Very True.
#5 Posted by reva315 on November 12, 2005 5:50:33 am
Shandana,
this piece echoes through the now-empty corridors of my own past. Babies are the ultimate naysayers to their mothers` intellectual growth but enormously fulfilling emotional highs.
This is an absolutely brilliant summing up of fears and fantasies and the reasons why women do not become heads not just of advertising agencies, or the UN or even famous artists. Can you imagine a baby crawling around where ther is wet paint flowing?
The only consolation I can offer is that babies become grown men and women and you recede into their past, or into the dark corners of their mutilated imaginations and psyches!!
Revathy Gopal
this piece echoes through the now-empty corridors of my own past. Babies are the ultimate naysayers to their mothers` intellectual growth but enormously fulfilling emotional highs.
This is an absolutely brilliant summing up of fears and fantasies and the reasons why women do not become heads not just of advertising agencies, or the UN or even famous artists. Can you imagine a baby crawling around where ther is wet paint flowing?
The only consolation I can offer is that babies become grown men and women and you recede into their past, or into the dark corners of their mutilated imaginations and psyches!!
Revathy Gopal
#4 Posted by ziahmed on November 11, 2005 12:37:14 pm
Funny AND powerful! Super writing, Shandana.
Wowzers!
I was now a vaginal bobby sock filled with shifting sands; a menacing uterine baton with a mind of its own.
Wowzers!
#3 Posted by PM on November 11, 2005 12:09:32 pm
Shandana,
You write:
``I am no longer an intelligent woman. I am a nearsighted biological function.``
But this piece suggests otherwise.
``I liked change better when it happened to other people.``
Maybe that`s your `original` sin-- yearning for a becomingness that essentially, you know deep inside, can never be fullfilled. (Is that the ride? hmm...)
But maybe it`s all vanity anyway. Maybe.
Look at the bright side. By all accounts here, you`re still a brilliant writer. And now there are potentially two more in the making -- whether there`s a writing gene or not! :)
There`s a great book by Camille Paglia that I`d like to lend you.
best wishes,
P.
You write:
``I am no longer an intelligent woman. I am a nearsighted biological function.``
But this piece suggests otherwise.
``I liked change better when it happened to other people.``
Maybe that`s your `original` sin-- yearning for a becomingness that essentially, you know deep inside, can never be fullfilled. (Is that the ride? hmm...)
But maybe it`s all vanity anyway. Maybe.
Look at the bright side. By all accounts here, you`re still a brilliant writer. And now there are potentially two more in the making -- whether there`s a writing gene or not! :)
There`s a great book by Camille Paglia that I`d like to lend you.
best wishes,
P.
#2 Posted by HN on November 11, 2005 4:39:39 am
Shandana,
Thanks! It has been years since I read a piece that held me. Thank you. Briliiant. I somehow remembered a quote from Sylvia Plath...``all women love a brute!``... This has that dark brodding that flashes with incite and insight...so Plathish...in theme. I like your dash of humour that spices up the final piece.
It was illuminating! PLease write.
HN
Thanks! It has been years since I read a piece that held me. Thank you. Briliiant. I somehow remembered a quote from Sylvia Plath...``all women love a brute!``... This has that dark brodding that flashes with incite and insight...so Plathish...in theme. I like your dash of humour that spices up the final piece.
It was illuminating! PLease write.
HN
#1 Posted by burpinder on November 10, 2005 11:06:49 pm
Shandana, you are one amazing writer. If you keep contributing regularly rather than pop up once in a blue moon, my visits to chowk FP will increase.
BTW, this seemed like a logical prose sequel to:
Bloated Woman
Shandana Minhas
February 18, 2002
Till now weeks were measured
in work assignments,
visits to parents,
farscape episodes,
leg hair growth,
substances abused
and manic episodes.
Now weeks aren’t measured
but meted out
in fetal inches,
meetings
missed,
as heart rate
accelerates,
belly
bloats.
…
Bloated woman once
floated free,
unhindered by
the mysteries
of diaper changing
spit exchanging
feeding times
and baby crimes.
Bloated woman
will you now be
up to task
and problem free
in time for this
delivery?
And bloated woman,
if you’re not,
can you return
to trouble spot?
Extinguish light,
dampen desire?
Perhaps defer
this imminent fire?
Bloated woman
won’t you speak?
Why so silent?
Why so meek?
…
Bounce around
ultrasound
baby.
Smack down
this brown
mummy.
I know where you live.
.....
That last verse is my favourite. BTW, what you went (and are going) through is true not just for women, though of course it`sobviously stronger since you do the actual biological part of it! Men **also** face the old family-versus-career runabout sometime around the time we turn 30. It tends to fade away by around 35, by which time we have realised that:
- we aint doing that well in our careers; and/or
- our families hate us anyway!
Keep writing, slink!
BTW, this seemed like a logical prose sequel to:
Bloated Woman
Shandana Minhas
February 18, 2002
Till now weeks were measured
in work assignments,
visits to parents,
farscape episodes,
leg hair growth,
substances abused
and manic episodes.
Now weeks aren’t measured
but meted out
in fetal inches,
meetings
missed,
as heart rate
accelerates,
belly
bloats.
…
Bloated woman once
floated free,
unhindered by
the mysteries
of diaper changing
spit exchanging
feeding times
and baby crimes.
Bloated woman
will you now be
up to task
and problem free
in time for this
delivery?
And bloated woman,
if you’re not,
can you return
to trouble spot?
Extinguish light,
dampen desire?
Perhaps defer
this imminent fire?
Bloated woman
won’t you speak?
Why so silent?
Why so meek?
…
Bounce around
ultrasound
baby.
Smack down
this brown
mummy.
I know where you live.
.....
That last verse is my favourite. BTW, what you went (and are going) through is true not just for women, though of course it`sobviously stronger since you do the actual biological part of it! Men **also** face the old family-versus-career runabout sometime around the time we turn 30. It tends to fade away by around 35, by which time we have realised that:
- we aint doing that well in our careers; and/or
- our families hate us anyway!
Keep writing, slink!
listing 16-32
1
2
Interact Index
Similar Articles
- Losing the Battle, Losing the Faith Ehtisham Iqbal
- Three Cups of Tea & Pennies for Peace Ras Siddiqui
- Not to Forget the Devastation of October 8, 2005 Earthquake Adnan Bashir
- Rape Survivor Families Struggle Against Odds Beena Sarwar
- Demon Sahir Shah
US Elections 2008 Primaries
Latest Interacts
- kashkin: RAS, I remember reading "Three... Three Cups of Tea
- ajeya: #51 Posted by hamidm2 [...... ‘Dustbin of history’ or
- hamidm2: Re: # 52 nkg mian, "The... ‘Dustbin of history’ or
- pinku: now in bold so... Terrorism Accused: Is Legal
- pinku: #51 Posted by mohar11... Terrorism Accused: Is Legal
- MeiraJ08: Ras, good to see... Three Cups of Tea
- mohar11: People have to realize... Terrorism Accused: Is Legal
- mohar11: harish that article in "india... Terrorism Accused: Is Legal








reply to this interact
write a new interact
add to favorites
flag objectionable content