Kamran Malik July 12, 2006
#16 Posted by nasah on July 20, 2006 9:30:34 pm
Zidane to work with children as penalty for his headbutt
BEN GLADWELL
ZINEDINE Zidane is to carry out three days of community service after the headbutting incident that marred the World Cup final, football`s governing body declared yesterday.
The French footballing legend was fined 7,500 Swiss francs (£3,360) and given a nominal three-match ban, but because he has since quit football it was agreed that he will do three days of community service with children as part of FIFA`s humanitarian projects.
The Italy defender Marco Materazzi was told he must pay 5,000 francs (£2,170) and received a two-game suspension for provoking the incident. Italy, who had been under pressure before Zidane was sent off during extra time with the game poised at 1-1, went on to win 5-3 on penalties.
The ruling means Materazzi will miss Italy`s trip to Paris for their Euro 2008 qualifier against the French on 6 September, as well as their match against Lithuania in Naples four days earlier. FIFA confirmed the Italian defender`s comments to Zidane had not been of a racist nature.
World football`s organising body also confirmed that Zidane, who earned £8.87 million in 2005, would keep his golden ball award as the tournament`s best player.
Zidane`s sending-off hit the French at a time when they appeared to be getting on top and deprived them of their best penalty-taker. The midfielder later complained that Materazzi had provoked him with remarks about his family. FIFA, while excluding any racial element, has not disclosed exactly what the Italian said.
Both players have a history of disciplinary troubles, and the sending-off was the 14th of Zidane`s career and his second in a World Cup - he picked up a two-match ban for stamping on a Saudi Arabian opponent in the 1998 tournament, won by France.
Materazzi is widely remembered in England for the three red cards he picked up in just 32 appearances for Everton.
BEN GLADWELL
ZINEDINE Zidane is to carry out three days of community service after the headbutting incident that marred the World Cup final, football`s governing body declared yesterday.
The French footballing legend was fined 7,500 Swiss francs (£3,360) and given a nominal three-match ban, but because he has since quit football it was agreed that he will do three days of community service with children as part of FIFA`s humanitarian projects.
The Italy defender Marco Materazzi was told he must pay 5,000 francs (£2,170) and received a two-game suspension for provoking the incident. Italy, who had been under pressure before Zidane was sent off during extra time with the game poised at 1-1, went on to win 5-3 on penalties.
The ruling means Materazzi will miss Italy`s trip to Paris for their Euro 2008 qualifier against the French on 6 September, as well as their match against Lithuania in Naples four days earlier. FIFA confirmed the Italian defender`s comments to Zidane had not been of a racist nature.
World football`s organising body also confirmed that Zidane, who earned £8.87 million in 2005, would keep his golden ball award as the tournament`s best player.
Zidane`s sending-off hit the French at a time when they appeared to be getting on top and deprived them of their best penalty-taker. The midfielder later complained that Materazzi had provoked him with remarks about his family. FIFA, while excluding any racial element, has not disclosed exactly what the Italian said.
Both players have a history of disciplinary troubles, and the sending-off was the 14th of Zidane`s career and his second in a World Cup - he picked up a two-match ban for stamping on a Saudi Arabian opponent in the 1998 tournament, won by France.
Materazzi is widely remembered in England for the three red cards he picked up in just 32 appearances for Everton.
#15 Posted by nasah on July 19, 2006 2:34:47 pm
Legal challenge to World Cup result
A French lawyer plans to mount a legal challenge to the World Cup final result to establish whether the expulsion of Zinedine Zidane was within the rules.
Mehana Mouhou said he intended to ask a Paris court to question the fourth official to ascertain whether he had illegally used videotape to check what had happened.
``If a judge determines that illegal methods were used, the proper consequences must be drawn,`` he said. ``That means that Zidane should never have been sent off and it would be impossible to predict what the match result would have been and it should be replayed.``
Mouhou said he was acting on behalf of ``several football clubs.``
A French lawyer plans to mount a legal challenge to the World Cup final result to establish whether the expulsion of Zinedine Zidane was within the rules.
Mehana Mouhou said he intended to ask a Paris court to question the fourth official to ascertain whether he had illegally used videotape to check what had happened.
``If a judge determines that illegal methods were used, the proper consequences must be drawn,`` he said. ``That means that Zidane should never have been sent off and it would be impossible to predict what the match result would have been and it should be replayed.``
Mouhou said he was acting on behalf of ``several football clubs.``
#14 Posted by iron_mask on July 19, 2006 4:21:08 am
The real question is When does a game stop being a a game?
when you have social scientists and other jobsworthies and assorted jobless wonders pontificating on the meaning of a game, and the real meaning of incidents taking place in the game. So take for example the Zidane case. Its pure and simple case of one player coaxing (and goading )the other to take drastic action and law into his hands, there by eliminating his threat from the game. The two players have played together at club level, part of the same team etc and know the soft spots. Its gamesmanship. But to attribute a higher meaning to this is silly and ridiculous.
I for one thought Zidane was true to form and did the right thing - head butting the player. Football is after all an extremely rough game. A game created by ruffians and the no good dregs of the society,,/b> with the rules super imposed, by a snobbish middle class, to bring some order to these hooligans. What Zidane did was in the spirit of the original creators of the game. What the Italian guy did was also within the same framework. The Intellectuals should stop bringing in their middle class sensibilities and insecurities and above all their sniffyness to this beautiful game played by over paid hooligans
when you have social scientists and other jobsworthies and assorted jobless wonders pontificating on the meaning of a game, and the real meaning of incidents taking place in the game. So take for example the Zidane case. Its pure and simple case of one player coaxing (and goading )the other to take drastic action and law into his hands, there by eliminating his threat from the game. The two players have played together at club level, part of the same team etc and know the soft spots. Its gamesmanship. But to attribute a higher meaning to this is silly and ridiculous.
I for one thought Zidane was true to form and did the right thing - head butting the player. Football is after all an extremely rough game. A game created by ruffians and the no good dregs of the society,,/b> with the rules super imposed, by a snobbish middle class, to bring some order to these hooligans. What Zidane did was in the spirit of the original creators of the game. What the Italian guy did was also within the same framework. The Intellectuals should stop bringing in their middle class sensibilities and insecurities and above all their sniffyness to this beautiful game played by over paid hooligans
#13 Posted by nasah on July 18, 2006 9:33:57 pm
PARIS: France defender Lilian Thuram disagreed with Zinedine Zidane’s head-butt in the World Cup final and said the Italy player who provoked him was hurting football.
Thuram said in an interview published yesterday by the weekly Les Inrockuptibles that he understood Zidane’s reaction to Marco Materazzi for insulting his family but that the timing was wrong.
Zidane, France’s captain, rammed Materazzi in extra time and was sent off. France lost 5-3 on penalties.
Thuram said he and Zidane, who planned to retire after the final, spoke briefly after the game.
“Materazzi insulted his family. I understand that Zidane reacted. But not on the field, not on the field,’’ Thuram said. “He made a mistake and he knows it. To be clear, I don’t think it affected the result. But, well, Zidane knows that he was tricked.’’
Players like Materazzi hurt the game, Thuram was quoted as saying.
“This type of player is a sickness. It shouldn’t exist ... Materazzi gives a negative image to football,’’ Thuram said.
Materazzi has admitted insulting Zidane, but denied he verbally attacked his mother.
FIFA is conducting an investigation. Materazzi appeared before a disciplinary committee last Friday, and Zidane is scheduled to appear on Thursday.
Zidane apologised to mainly children on French TV last week, and said he did not regret the incident because Materazzi insulted his mother and sister. – AP
Thuram said in an interview published yesterday by the weekly Les Inrockuptibles that he understood Zidane’s reaction to Marco Materazzi for insulting his family but that the timing was wrong.
Zidane, France’s captain, rammed Materazzi in extra time and was sent off. France lost 5-3 on penalties.
Thuram said he and Zidane, who planned to retire after the final, spoke briefly after the game.
“Materazzi insulted his family. I understand that Zidane reacted. But not on the field, not on the field,’’ Thuram said. “He made a mistake and he knows it. To be clear, I don’t think it affected the result. But, well, Zidane knows that he was tricked.’’
Players like Materazzi hurt the game, Thuram was quoted as saying.
“This type of player is a sickness. It shouldn’t exist ... Materazzi gives a negative image to football,’’ Thuram said.
Materazzi has admitted insulting Zidane, but denied he verbally attacked his mother.
FIFA is conducting an investigation. Materazzi appeared before a disciplinary committee last Friday, and Zidane is scheduled to appear on Thursday.
Zidane apologised to mainly children on French TV last week, and said he did not regret the incident because Materazzi insulted his mother and sister. – AP
#12 Posted by nasah on July 17, 2006 7:12:14 am
Zidane family says Metarazzi was provoking Zidane throughout the game calling him a terrorista -- leading to the ugly confrontation when the Italian insulted his family.
Insults, taunts are nothing unusual for world games -- this game was one of the worst of finals in fouls and injured acting.
Zidane a 34 year old captain of the team should not have done what he did and was rightly punished -- but he was not the first one to butt head -- it has happened several times in world games before with referees paying to attention to it because the acts did not happen during the tackle.
France lost because of David Trezeguet not Zidane -- Zidane the magician, the wizard is stilll the greatest soccer player of the world right now and will remain so in future.
Insults, taunts are nothing unusual for world games -- this game was one of the worst of finals in fouls and injured acting.
Zidane a 34 year old captain of the team should not have done what he did and was rightly punished -- but he was not the first one to butt head -- it has happened several times in world games before with referees paying to attention to it because the acts did not happen during the tackle.
France lost because of David Trezeguet not Zidane -- Zidane the magician, the wizard is stilll the greatest soccer player of the world right now and will remain so in future.
#11 Posted by km007 on July 15, 2006 12:34:47 am
The Crying Fields of Football
———————————————
Football fields will cry with Zidane no more to bring grace and elegance to the sport
Football fields cried when foul words were the crowning glory of the champions
So reads the epitaph of the “Beautiful Game” which was laid to rest in Berlin on July 9th, 2006
———————————————
Football fields will cry with Zidane no more to bring grace and elegance to the sport
Football fields cried when foul words were the crowning glory of the champions
So reads the epitaph of the “Beautiful Game” which was laid to rest in Berlin on July 9th, 2006
#10 Posted by kaami on July 14, 2006 7:20:08 am
although what Materazzi did was not exactly bookable but i`m sure that must`ve been something very provocative because otherwise i don`t see zizou doing such an irresponsible thing
zidane has already been pardoned (or forgiven or condoned) by majority of the french as a recent poll suggests and he has also made it all clear in his official statement on the issue
but something i found strange was the coverage of the incident... most tv channels decided not to show the scene before the head-but in the replays.... i think the point Urstruly has made is playing a big part here
i don`t think france lost the world cup due to zizou because the way the italians took their penalty kicks, it would have taken an ubermensch effort to stop any
i guessed they had practiced really hard after having lost at penalties on 4 out of 5 important occasions
and well said notre_dame... a hero`s got to do what a hero`s got to do... and zidane definitely is a hero for football lovers around the world
P.S. Zizou was absolutely MAJESTIC in the match against Brazil
zidane has already been pardoned (or forgiven or condoned) by majority of the french as a recent poll suggests and he has also made it all clear in his official statement on the issue
but something i found strange was the coverage of the incident... most tv channels decided not to show the scene before the head-but in the replays.... i think the point Urstruly has made is playing a big part here
i don`t think france lost the world cup due to zizou because the way the italians took their penalty kicks, it would have taken an ubermensch effort to stop any
i guessed they had practiced really hard after having lost at penalties on 4 out of 5 important occasions
and well said notre_dame... a hero`s got to do what a hero`s got to do... and zidane definitely is a hero for football lovers around the world
P.S. Zizou was absolutely MAJESTIC in the match against Brazil
#9 Posted by kai on July 14, 2006 2:36:19 am
Issue: React or not react to provocation
Action choices: React with (escalated) violence and satisfy the lizard brain or not react (with a like level of force) and satisfy the forebrain
Mitigation: React immediately with a like level of force (verbal abuse in this case), or channel emotion into competing harder (not dirtier)
Resolution: Realize that football is a microcosm of the world at large and we all must make choices based upon our own value systems. Make your choice and then abide by the consequences.
Footnote: Had it been me I wouldn`t have head-butted Materazzi in the chest, I would have given him back the boyfriend hug he gave earlier and then mashed his balls in my hand; I don`t believe there`s any red-carding for excessive shows of affection on the field.
Action choices: React with (escalated) violence and satisfy the lizard brain or not react (with a like level of force) and satisfy the forebrain
Mitigation: React immediately with a like level of force (verbal abuse in this case), or channel emotion into competing harder (not dirtier)
Resolution: Realize that football is a microcosm of the world at large and we all must make choices based upon our own value systems. Make your choice and then abide by the consequences.
Footnote: Had it been me I wouldn`t have head-butted Materazzi in the chest, I would have given him back the boyfriend hug he gave earlier and then mashed his balls in my hand; I don`t believe there`s any red-carding for excessive shows of affection on the field.
#8 Posted by Kulharee on July 13, 2006 11:46:26 am
You used nipple 22 times in this writeup. Is this about nipples or football? Also, in a few days no one will remember Zidane or Materazzi, but everyone will remember that Italy won the Cup.
I watched the closeup of the head butt, it shows that Zidane headbutted right on Materazzi’s nipple. The left one.
I watched the closeup of the head butt, it shows that Zidane headbutted right on Materazzi’s nipple. The left one.
#7 Posted by pakihunk on July 13, 2006 9:12:29 am
=== Interact Filtered ===
view this users filtered interacts
view this users filtered interacts
#6 Posted by oak on July 13, 2006 8:52:16 am
Ofcourse, Zidane shouldn`t have done it. He was the oldest player on the field. Provocation is routine at this level of football. Didn`t he expect it? And yes, he probably lost France the World Cup. Penalties after all is a psychological game. With Zidane off, and Henri not on the field, Italy just had to hold their nerve. Trezeguet`s & even Wiltord`s reactions before the penalties betrayed their lack of confidence.
But does it really put a dark spot against Zidane`s record? Plenty of talented players have had their moments at the end of their career eg Hagi & Cantona. Zidane will be remembered for the genius he was rather than anything else.
What do you wish for the player who has won everything? Another world cup?
But does it really put a dark spot against Zidane`s record? Plenty of talented players have had their moments at the end of their career eg Hagi & Cantona. Zidane will be remembered for the genius he was rather than anything else.
What do you wish for the player who has won everything? Another world cup?
#5 Posted by Urstruly on July 13, 2006 7:28:59 am
The Zidane incident is the inevitable outcome of the racist and isolationist policies that several European governments have adopted to suppress their Muslim populations. Most probably by the next two world cups the colored players in general and Muslims in particular will be phased out completely from the teams.
#4 Posted by notre_dame on July 13, 2006 3:23:22 am
``And I don`t regret anything that happened, I accept it.`` (zidane)
Materazzi got what he asked for. Italians got the cup but zidane`s still high on the popularity poll.
His apology was directed to his fans, not the Italian team or FIFA. Also he didnt challenge the referee`s decision. A hero`s gotta do what he`s gotta do. bon courage zidane =)
Materazzi got what he asked for. Italians got the cup but zidane`s still high on the popularity poll.
His apology was directed to his fans, not the Italian team or FIFA. Also he didnt challenge the referee`s decision. A hero`s gotta do what he`s gotta do. bon courage zidane =)
#3 Posted by PM on July 13, 2006 12:25:07 am
Zidane doesn`t need `condoning` by anyone except his teammates and coach (and maybe, by the French nation) -- but only to the extent that he let his team down by not playing 10 minutes of the match.
He certainly does not need condoning for the PHYSICAL act of headbutting. They are all big boys and well inured to this level of physical agression, and in fact, take a lot worse day in and day out from nasty tackles. (For an example of what cannot be condoned, IMHO, watch the elbow-to-the-face that DelRossi(Italy) gave McBride (USA).)
So please, let`s not flog this dead horse no more... Zidane was provoked, he reacted (perhaps irresponsibily) and was red carded for it. Big Deal! Happens all the time in football. I reckon Zizou wouldn`t have reacted that way 10 miniutes INTO the match, as opposed to 10 minutes to the end of it.
He certainly does not need condoning for the PHYSICAL act of headbutting. They are all big boys and well inured to this level of physical agression, and in fact, take a lot worse day in and day out from nasty tackles. (For an example of what cannot be condoned, IMHO, watch the elbow-to-the-face that DelRossi(Italy) gave McBride (USA).)
So please, let`s not flog this dead horse no more... Zidane was provoked, he reacted (perhaps irresponsibily) and was red carded for it. Big Deal! Happens all the time in football. I reckon Zizou wouldn`t have reacted that way 10 miniutes INTO the match, as opposed to 10 minutes to the end of it.
#2 Posted by zero_tolerance on July 12, 2006 11:34:51 pm
If you think nipple-pinching and shirt-tugging is a bookable offence then dude you should stick or go back to cricket. I have no idea how people like you get published.
And if you ask what Materazzi will do next, the answer is another `high-foot` or another `elbow` or another pinch here and there. Zidane`s header was provoked, yes, but it was full of intent and purpose as clearly seen in the video. Turning around, and giving it all the power he had.
You wont get `red card` for cursing, if with-in certian reasonable limits. Zidane is older than Materazzi, and more experienced with hard hitting defenders, he should have have had a go at it too.
Zidane deserved to be red carded and he didnt even plea after that, not saying he should have begged, but he was standing there as if he knew the consequence. He also deserves to be stipped of the Golden Ball award.
And if you ask what Materazzi will do next, the answer is another `high-foot` or another `elbow` or another pinch here and there. Zidane`s header was provoked, yes, but it was full of intent and purpose as clearly seen in the video. Turning around, and giving it all the power he had.
You wont get `red card` for cursing, if with-in certian reasonable limits. Zidane is older than Materazzi, and more experienced with hard hitting defenders, he should have have had a go at it too.
Zidane deserved to be red carded and he didnt even plea after that, not saying he should have begged, but he was standing there as if he knew the consequence. He also deserves to be stipped of the Golden Ball award.
#1 Posted by farhanfaiz on July 12, 2006 11:25:53 pm
i do not think so that ``One can not condone Zidane`s act,`` is a fair statement. No matter what you do, you are responsible for it.
Zidane act can not be justified by any statement made by Materazzi. All black players listen arguments about raceism and other things, so they start doing what Zadine has done. I am not justifying Materazzi act but we have a saying ``If dog bites you, you do not start bitting the dog``.
One should see by doing this who is getting the benefit. At the end who suffers. Zadine did what was not accrding to his standerds. He is like GOD in FOOTBALL ARENA and he proved himself as just another human being.
Zidane act can not be justified by any statement made by Materazzi. All black players listen arguments about raceism and other things, so they start doing what Zadine has done. I am not justifying Materazzi act but we have a saying ``If dog bites you, you do not start bitting the dog``.
One should see by doing this who is getting the benefit. At the end who suffers. Zadine did what was not accrding to his standerds. He is like GOD in FOOTBALL ARENA and he proved himself as just another human being.
Interact Index
Similar Articles
- Government Wins Manmohan Singh Loses Dost Mittar
- Feminist Mumbo-Jumbo! Pranay Rupani
- Translation of a (Love) Letter by Allama Iqbal to Miss Atiya Faizi Asif Naqshbandi
- Fields Of Joy Umer Murtaza
- Time for Musharraf to Quit saeed qureshi
US Elections 2008 Primaries
Latest Interacts
- kaurasach: Islam is in conlict... Dhokha and Being a
- anil: Re: # 42 Dost sahib: I... Government Wins Manmohan Singh
- dost_mittar: dehliwala#48: I am not a... Government Wins Manmohan Singh
- dost_mittar: GT#47: Yes, we do and... Government Wins Manmohan Singh
- guru: Ahmed, We had come to... Dhokha and Being a
- sattar2: tahir bhai (re #408),... Of Medical Students, Passports
- guru: Re: # 283 "After... Dhokha and Being a
- mohar11: looks like Guru kicked... Dhokha and Being a








reply to this interact
write a new interact
add to favorites
flag objectionable content