Amrita Rajan January 26, 2005
#15 Posted by amrita on February 1, 2005 2:49:10 am
t - No, no – not a whining grouch, surely. : -) In fact, not a grouch at all...
As for involvement in mafia orgs, there are some like the D company for eg. But they can almost always trace their roots back to the home country. I believe there are a lot of arms dealers of desi persuasion abroad as well. The well heeled tend to stick to the more profitable and less dirty white collar variety. Knew a whole lot of well heeled young Indians in India who were into mafia stuff and common thuggery though. Most of the desi kids I met abroad (America and Britain) stuck to run-of-the-mill hustling and drugs.
Thothoewing – thank you for your…er, valuable input. After according it the consideration it deserved, I regret that my personal proclivity forbids me to carry out violence upon my person. I am, of course, desolated.
Lakhania - so I`ve heard, so I`ve heard...
As for involvement in mafia orgs, there are some like the D company for eg. But they can almost always trace their roots back to the home country. I believe there are a lot of arms dealers of desi persuasion abroad as well. The well heeled tend to stick to the more profitable and less dirty white collar variety. Knew a whole lot of well heeled young Indians in India who were into mafia stuff and common thuggery though. Most of the desi kids I met abroad (America and Britain) stuck to run-of-the-mill hustling and drugs.
Thothoewing – thank you for your…er, valuable input. After according it the consideration it deserved, I regret that my personal proclivity forbids me to carry out violence upon my person. I am, of course, desolated.
Lakhania - so I`ve heard, so I`ve heard...
#14 Posted by lakhania on February 1, 2005 1:25:13 am
Re: # 13
“It’s a free country, dude! You can hardly see it any more but it’s still a free country.”
“It’s a free country, dude! You can hardly see it any more but it’s still a free country.”
#13 Posted by ThothoEwing on January 31, 2005 12:05:19 pm
What kachra this ABCD is writing? Needs a firm slap to get all this out of her brain.
#12 Posted by temporal on January 31, 2005 10:53:18 am
amrita:
arey baba refrain from painting me as a super whining grouch here;)...did i not mention ( #7) my comments were chowk-specific...yes i did!...khair...am just rambling...and yes, second rahul!...
HERE are some early morning digressions:)
lve
t
arey baba refrain from painting me as a super whining grouch here;)...did i not mention ( #7) my comments were chowk-specific...yes i did!...khair...am just rambling...and yes, second rahul!...
HERE are some early morning digressions:)
lve
t
#11 Posted by rahul_capri on January 30, 2005 10:08:21 pm
Re: # 10
Amrita, keep writing and sharing.Its great to have you on chowk.
Amrita, keep writing and sharing.Its great to have you on chowk.
#10 Posted by amrita on January 30, 2005 9:13:17 pm
Re: # 9
Rahul,
You`re absolutely right and no, it wasn`t a stylistic experiment in the strictest sense. It was more an experiment with characters and language. The narrators of all my pieces tend to be strong, whether they be men or women, but I try my best to keep faith with their `natural` voice. However, I`m not comfortable with the immediate tense that I employed here nor do I write `everyday` or profane (for eg, how much is too much?) very well.
This was an attempt to do both and it`s apparently not so dusty. My usual writing voice is very different and comes far more naturally to me - ``Bubbles`` is an example. But it`s a bit tiring to write a novel in it and then keep writing shorts in it too (esp when they`re not very short as t pointed out :-) ). There were elements in this story that interested me and a literary style would have stifled it - in my opinion. I had fun with it.
Rahul,
You`re absolutely right and no, it wasn`t a stylistic experiment in the strictest sense. It was more an experiment with characters and language. The narrators of all my pieces tend to be strong, whether they be men or women, but I try my best to keep faith with their `natural` voice. However, I`m not comfortable with the immediate tense that I employed here nor do I write `everyday` or profane (for eg, how much is too much?) very well.
This was an attempt to do both and it`s apparently not so dusty. My usual writing voice is very different and comes far more naturally to me - ``Bubbles`` is an example. But it`s a bit tiring to write a novel in it and then keep writing shorts in it too (esp when they`re not very short as t pointed out :-) ). There were elements in this story that interested me and a literary style would have stifled it - in my opinion. I had fun with it.
#9 Posted by rahul_capri on January 30, 2005 8:24:24 am
samankhan #5 :-), exactly my thoughts.
Amrita, somehow I get the feeling that experimentation was an end in itself in this piece,all other things taking a backseat. Did you employ any specific method?
Amrita, somehow I get the feeling that experimentation was an end in itself in this piece,all other things taking a backseat. Did you employ any specific method?
#8 Posted by amrita on January 29, 2005 10:12:58 pm
Samankhan - experimentation is the name of the game.... :-)
Usama - no offense taken. I like constructive criticism, it hones my craft. Why did I write this? Because everyone keeps writing about the industrious South Asian who smells like curry and breaks his back to put dollars in the bank account while dreaming of the green fields of Punjab. I`ve even had taxi drivers harangue me on the subject and I`m sick and tired of it. The aimless young junkies in this story are real ppl who`re going to run the world tomorrow. And this was fiction - the truth is almost unprintable (ha!)
t - thank you! yeah verbosity is a big problem. I keep trying to cut down but all my stories start at the dada-pardada level before getting down to the nitty gritty. This one was an experiment that grew and grew until I just stopped.
Thanks for reading....
Usama - no offense taken. I like constructive criticism, it hones my craft. Why did I write this? Because everyone keeps writing about the industrious South Asian who smells like curry and breaks his back to put dollars in the bank account while dreaming of the green fields of Punjab. I`ve even had taxi drivers harangue me on the subject and I`m sick and tired of it. The aimless young junkies in this story are real ppl who`re going to run the world tomorrow. And this was fiction - the truth is almost unprintable (ha!)
t - thank you! yeah verbosity is a big problem. I keep trying to cut down but all my stories start at the dada-pardada level before getting down to the nitty gritty. This one was an experiment that grew and grew until I just stopped.
Thanks for reading....
#7 Posted by temporal on January 29, 2005 8:57:43 pm
amrita:
tum achcha likhti ho!
…have a few chowk-specific comments:
--at 5261 words it is a difficult read on a small screen…1000-1500 max is ideal…any more and one needs to print out and read later…
--the first person narration was unobtrusive…you pulled it off well
--too many characters …in a way they diluted the effect…
lve
t
tum achcha likhti ho!
…have a few chowk-specific comments:
--at 5261 words it is a difficult read on a small screen…1000-1500 max is ideal…any more and one needs to print out and read later…
--the first person narration was unobtrusive…you pulled it off well
--too many characters …in a way they diluted the effect…
lve
t
#6 Posted by Usama_Ashfaq on January 29, 2005 4:51:59 pm
Now what the hell was that all about, i hope u donot mind (the author) but i donot understand the point of narrating the sights & sounds of a party that u arranged for ur friends and their friends. I thought chowk was a place for serious, focussed kind of debate, not about someone presenting her analysis of different people from different backgrounds and their behaviours under the effect of narcotics. i hope no one is offended. Even, If u categorize the above narration into the category of a social commentary, there are far better topics then a discussion involving drugs and a bunch of directionless young people.
I hope u take it as constructive criticism.
I hope u take it as constructive criticism.
#2 Posted by Saminasha on January 27, 2005 6:28:55 am
But the narrator`s tone and some of the subplots and main plot done quite well!
Interact Index
Similar Articles
- The Jehadi Frankenstein Ali Chishti
- I Want Jinnah's Pakistan Tariq Aqil
- Communicating Medical Errors Prashant Bhatt
- The Strange Case of the Indian Channels That Did Not Air the 26/11 Documentary Vivek Balaraman
- Why MQM Wants To Enter Punjab? Nadia Khan
Swat: Paradise Lost
Latest Interacts
- SureshM: Re: # 36 God Bless... Uneven Democracy : The
- SureshM: Re: # 59 "kuwait... I Want Jinnah's Pakistan
- ahmedmadani: Re: # 35 this... Uneven Democracy : The
- jayp: Re: # 55 Good muslim... I Want Jinnah's Pakistan
- jayp: Re: # 53 thanks madani... I Want Jinnah's Pakistan
- Pardesi: Breaking News for ahmedmadani... Uneven Democracy : The
- a_r_j_u_n325: #94 Posted by... The Strange Case of
- a_r_j_u_n325: #95 Posted by... The Strange Case of








reply to this interact
write a new interact
add to favorites
flag objectionable content